Pullman Bay - Celina

#11 - Mexican - Celina, American, Breakfast
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Pullman Bay

Pullman Bay
4.3 / 5 (4245 reviews)

Description

The Bay, a lakeside café formerly known as Pullman Bay, is a beloved local spot for hearty breakfasts, lunches and homemade pies, buoyed by friendly, attentive staff and a sunny mural. Standout items include excellent hollandaise and freshly baked pies, though it’s often busy. Under new ownership some guests note smaller portions, inconsistent food quality and limited hours—dinner has been discontinued—and there are reports of poor allergy accommodation and occasional slow service.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: MikeC

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 4245 reviews
mikec
07.10.2024

This place is no longer known as Pullman Bay, simply The Bay. Under new management a year and a half ago, they stopped serving dinner, but still do terrific breakfast and lunch as well. It’s a great spot right on the lake, jampacked with hungry, locals, and well served by very polite and friendly weight staff. We had just about every kind of breakfast imaginable all on one table and it was absolutely delicious.

teresa-oconnell-2
07.10.2024

The view was spectacular. Our waitress was fabulous and the food was fantastic! You can’t do any better than that. We were at the Eldora Speedway for the races and stopped in Celina, Ohio at the bay restaurant.

rob-van-14
07.10.2024

We visit The Pullman Bay Restaurant in Celina, at least once a week for a nice breakfast...the waitresses have always been very friendly to us...great coffee and food... love their homemade pies... A beautiful view of the lake, is a bonus... This restaurant is now called The Bay

careys-spam-3
07.10.2024

We're lucky to have this spot! love that I can walk or bike here for breakfast : It's all good Belgian waffles, bacon, goat cheese spinich omelets, smothered home fries, pancakes, gravy

vanessa-da-corte-3
07.10.2024

I recently had breakfast at Pullman Bay Restaurant and had a wonderful experience! The food was absolutely delicious, and the service was top notch our server was attentive and friendly. Unfortunately, they were out of their famous pie, which is usually the highlight of my visit! But I was thrilled to learn that they're currently training new staff to perfect the art of making this beloved dessert. I'm excited to come back soon and try the pie once again, and I'm confident it will be just as amazing as before. Keep up the great work, Pullman Bay!

FAQ

There is a TV / screen on-site where sports events are broadcast.

The restaurant and its premises are wheelchair accessible and thus reachable with a wheelchair or physical disabilities.

The place also accepts credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.