Highlander Pizza - Cave Spring

International, Pizza, Italian
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Highlander Pizza

Highlander Pizza
3.8 / 5 (162 reviews)

Menu

A complete menu of Highlander Pizza from Cave Spring featuring all 6 menus and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Madeline

Images

Highlander Pizza Food Highlander Pizza Food Highlander Pizza Menu Highlander Pizza Menu Highlander Pizza Menu Highlander Pizza Menu Highlander Pizza Menu Highlander Pizza Menu

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 162 reviews

Was Noah Shahinian at Highlander Pizza a mag?
Ignore the negative reviews. The owner puts in a lot of effort, and this place makes pizza better than anywhere else—trust me on that. I've sampled every pizza spot in the Roanoke Valley, and this one is the best. I've introduced at least a dozen people to his pizza, and they all keep coming back for more. If you're looking to try something different, don't miss the pizza rolls! View all feedback.

What Stephanie Diersing dislikes about Highlander Pizza:
When I order cheesecake at a restaurant, I expect them to at least make it look homemade by removing it from its packaging. I was also disappointed to find canned mushrooms on my plate. This makes me suspect that the rest of the food probably isn’t fresh either. You can easily tell when a restaurant values its ingredients, and it was clear this one did not. I won't be returning. View all feedback.

laith-saleh
01.09.2024

A very negative experience at this pizza restaurant! Found a hair in the pizza, received poor treatment from the staff, and the place was disgustingly dirty. I cannot imagine returning to this place again; the restaurant management must improve cleanliness and service immediately.

robin-hoke-mushroom2
01.09.2024

Pizza was great until my son found a sharp piece of metal on bottom of pizza crustI hope we didn't eat any of it and hopefully that was the only pieceWe definitely won't be going back there

adam-murphy-bush8475
01.09.2024

Got take out from here. Tried pretty much all the Roanoke area pizza places and Highlander and Grace's seem to be a step above the rest. Highlander's was a perfect take out pizza. Right combo of ingredients, toppings excellently spread, and not soggy and toppings dripping off (unlike some other places in town not named). I would say Highlander might be the best hand tossed but I haven't had their thin if they have one. Grace's is the place if you want thin but their hand tossed is also great.Will be ordering again!Anyway, definitely worth. Got a 16 inch large specialty for like 21 bucks. Only complaint was the pizza slices were cut super weird and inconsistent. One slice was a wee baby slice and one was a mammoth slice. Others were fine

madeline-richmond
01.09.2024

Best pizza around!

patti-m-4
01.09.2024

1st time going. I will definitely go back. Awesome food and people.

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.