New York - Catskill

Hipster, Romantic, Intimate, Classy, Casual, American, Polish
Reservation
Reservation request for New York.

New York

New York
4.5 / 5 (5058 reviews)

Description

Nestled in Catskill, NY, New York Restaurant is a highly regarded American dining destination, proudly boasting an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars. Diners rave about their experiences here. Open today from 4:30 PM to 9:30 PM, this upscale eatery invites you to make a reservation by calling (518) 943-5500 to ensure your table is ready. With a menu that accommodates vegetarian dietary options, there's something for everyone to savor. If you’re exploring nearby alternatives, don’t miss Mermaid Cafe and HiLo Catskill. We’d love to hear about your dining experience – feel free to leave a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Lia

Reservation request for New York

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 5058 reviews
shane-800
24.09.2023

Great food, great atmosphere. I tried it once and it was definitely different but good!!! Never had polish food before, but it was very tasty. The waitress that was helping us was attentive and on point. Even had a chance to meet the owner Natasha. Very nice woman. If you?re in Catskill and you want to know what polish food taste like I would recommend The New York Restaurant.

marisabel-santiago
24.09.2023

The restaurant is absolutely delicious with great service, making for a lovely evening. There is a small corkage fee of $15, but it is worth it if you bring a fancy bottle. On Tuesdays, they offer $5 margaritas with tacos. The gnocchi was cooked perfectly and the wild foraged mushrooms added an excellent flavor to the dish.

tyesun
24.09.2023

We were excited to try this restaurant. The food was delicious, atmosphere eclectic, but service the table next to us was HORRIBLE! We made a reservation for 4 but our friends had an emergency had to cancel so we gave up our table of four to eat at the bar. Let me start by saying the table directly behind us ?regulars? per the bartender) we?re discussing politics such with f-bombs and other profanities. When we finally turned around and asked him to keep it down , he said ?f-you? to us and continued ranting. The couple next to us at the bar were appalled as well! He just went on and on! The bartender said he was a ?regular? there. I?m not sure why you would let this ?regular? discuss politics profanities out loud ruin other customers meals?! Let me say it is a TURN OFF! I suggest sticking this realtor ?regular? far away from other customers if you want to stay in business. We complained to the owner all she said was ?really??. Not sure we?ll be back?!

lia29-1
16.05.2025

The drinks are delicious. They are unique and taste good. I had the Georgia this time. There was no wait with reservations. The waitress is friendly and very attentive. They switch their menu every few months for variety. The drinks are changed up tooevery few months. The food is great. I had the octopus dinner and my fiancé had the pinwheel sole. The dessert was delicious aswell. Great atmosphere. The prices are reasonable. They let you enjoy your meal instead of rushing you out the door.

viola36-1
16.05.2025

Great food, great atmosphere. I tried it once and it was definitely different but good!!! Never had polish food before, but it was very tasty. The waitress that was helping us was attentive and on point. Even had a chance to meet the owner Natasha. Verynice woman. If you’re in Catskill and you want to know what polish food taste like I would recommend The New York Restaurant.

FAQ

You can use the WLAN of the place at no extra cost.

The eatery is a non-smoking restaurant.

The restaurant also offers gluten-free meals.

The restaurant offers the opportunity to watch sports events on a TV / screen.

The rooms on site are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physical disabilities.

The restaurant also takes credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.