Paul's Pizza - Castleton

The pepperoni pizza was phenomenal, and the mozzarella sticks were huge and tasty. Definitely worth the trip from New read more The pepperoni pizza was phenomenal, and the mozzarella sticks were huge and tasty. Definitely worth the trip from New

Rude manager who canceled our order after almost 2 hours of waiting.. If your not a people person or can't handle complaints the right way. Get a new job.. read more Rude manager who canceled our order after almost 2 hours of waiting.. If your not a people person or can't handle complaints the right way. Get a new job..

Begin with the menu says there’s two different size subs, but there’s not. Just one size. Not a big deal. I ask if I can get meatball and sausage on the same su... read more Begin with the menu says there’s two different size subs, but there’s not. Just one size. Not a big deal. I ask if I can get meatball and sausage on the same sub together. I am told yes, but I have to pay for extra meat. I paid the fee for extra meat and I get a sub delivered that has four tiny meatballs inside of it, no sausage. Ridiculous.

Loved it but would rather have real silver ware not cheap plastic while eating a hot pizza.... but pizza was amazing read more Loved it but would rather have real silver ware not cheap plastic while eating a hot pizza.... but pizza was amazing

Update: after they saw my review the next day. They took a look at my ticket the saw that I was overcharged by mistake (person was new and made a mistake). The... read more Update: after they saw my review the next day. They took a look at my ticket the saw that I was overcharged by mistake (person was new and made a mistake). The owner called and then credited my bank card I used the amount overcharged. This has changed my opinion of going back. Like I said the food was very good. Although the pizza was good and the turkey sub was pretty good. A large 3 topping pizza and the sub came to $43. This is the reason I won't be coming back. I've never paid so much before anywhere else.