Old Chicago - Casper

#7 - Vegetarian - Casper, #23 - Pizza - Casper, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Old Chicago

Old Chicago
3.5 / 5 (1293 reviews)

Description

Nestled in the heart of Casper, this vibrant restaurant impresses with its mouthwatering menu and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for game days or casual outings. Diners rave about the double speck cheeseburger and delectable pretzel bites with beer cheese, while specialty dishes like the Chicago Fire calzone offer a flavorful twist. The attentive service stands out, with staff consistently praised for their warmth and efficiency, ensuring a memorable experience even during busy times. Although minor hiccups with food delivery may occur, the overall commitment to excellent customer service shines through, making this spot a must-visit for both locals and travelers alike.

Last update: 18.01.2026 from: Kathryn

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 1293 reviews
carl-115
05.08.2023

Been a long time since I last ate in old Chicago, today was passing through Casper I can say the whole restaurant gets the big WOW!! Staff up front during busy hour all had warm smiles and sat us quickly. Then got another warm greeting from Edel, all I can say from the beginning to the end I can say he hit it out of the ball park. Great service hard to come by,thanks for manger stopping by to check on our table and many others. If you are very hungry and passing by do make a stop...

anna-3744
05.08.2023

We stopped by while passing through town. The positives were a great salad, delicious salad dressing, and quick service. However, the negatives included the pizza. The thick crust pizza tastes just like Pizza Hut, so if that's what you consider good pizza, then you'll enjoy it. But if you're looking for those rich, flavorful Chicago-style pizzas, this place isn't the one for you.

kathryn-35
05.08.2023

Originally fell in love with this chain while living In Tennessee because of my favorite mixed drinks they serve there, the Sunset Beach. I generally drink beer but if I find a cocktail on a menu I really like that?s my go to. I don?t have a favorite food item on their menu yet as I don?t live close to one anymore and don?t eat at one often but I?ve never had a meal I didn?t like at one of these locations. I?ve tried pizza and calzones but hope to try their Mac and cheese and sandwich selections as well. They?ve got TVs for watching the games and this location seemed well staffed for a busy day, the food didn?t take long at all. Our waitress was fine, checked up on our table regularly to refill drinks but at the end did take a while to bring the check. The pretzel bites with beer cheese were good. Pictured here is the Chicago Fire calzone. It was good! But almost had too many strong flavors going on at once to be able to enjoy it. The ranch was a good pairing, it toned down some of these flavors. Good location, easy to get to from other places we shopped at passing through Casper.

kathryn-jones-dog07
07.06.2026

Originally fell in love with this chain while living In Tennessee because of my favorite mixed drinks they serve there, the Sunset Beach. I generally drink beer but if I find a cocktail on a menu I really like that’s my go to. I don’t have a favorite food item on their menu yet as I don’t live close to one anymore and don’t eat at one often but I’ve never had a meal I didn’t like at one of these locations. I’ve tried pizza and calzones but hope to try their Mac and cheese and sandwich selections

esther-johnson-tree4
07.06.2026

I'm personally giving this place a 4.5/5 stars ! I loved the bruschetta even though my S/O thought the bread should've been crisper (technically he was right but I still loved it). He tried the boneless wings and had a burger as his meal. The burger was cooked as it should be, and he said it was good but not necessarily something he would recommend to others. The boneless wings were also good. I had one of the specialty pizzas on the menu that had chicken and spinach. I ordered it thin crust wh

FAQ

The eatery is a non-smoking restaurant.

There is a TV / screen on-site where sporting events are shown.

The premises in the restaurant are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

The place accepts the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.