Lefty's Diner - Full Menu

Best dinner in town! The dough is incredibly light yet full of flavor. The only thing I considered adding was a bit of fresh lemon, but that's just a personal p... read more Best dinner in town! The dough is incredibly light yet full of flavor. The only thing I considered adding was a bit of fresh lemon, but that's just a personal preference. I also love the family-friendly atmosphere at the restaurant! I can't wait to come back to Caseville and enjoy another meal at Lefty's.

Once I had a chance to look over the menu for about five minutes, I was ready to order. I chose the Philly cheesesteak, while my mother opted for the cheese wit... read more Once I had a chance to look over the menu for about five minutes, I was ready to order. I chose the Philly cheesesteak, while my mother opted for the cheese with speck. Our meals arrived after around 10 to 12 minutes, and the portion sizes were just right—not too small, but not overly filling either. Overall, I had a great experience. The waitress was attentive and did her job well, and the food tasted really good. The prices were slightly on the high side, but not enough to be a concern. If I find myself in Caseville again, I would definitely consider stopping by Lefty’s once more. I would also recommend it to others traveling in that direction. I drove over an hour north to reach Caseville and I was not disappointed, making my trip a positive one.