Matthew's On Main St - Callicoon

American, Grill, Dive
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +18458875636

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Matthew's On Main St from Callicoon featuring all 10 menus and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Nestled in Sullivan County, this restaurant promises an unforgettable dining experience with its impressive variety of fresh dishes and attentive service. Guests rave about standout offerings like the smoked trout BLT and Chinese dumpling soup, often wishing for bigger portions. The warm, friendly ambiance complements its dive-style bar, perfect for enjoying a cold beer or catching the game. With options for brunch and spaces accommodating large gatherings, it's ideal for any occasion. The accommodating staff, led by the friendly owner and creative chef, ensures each visit is delightful. This gem is a must-visit for food lovers and locals alike.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Lisa

Images

Matthew's On Main St Food Matthew's On Main St Food Matthew's On Main St Food Matthew's On Main St Food Matthew's On Main St Food Matthew's On Main St Food Matthew's On Main St Food Matthew's On Main St Food

Feedback

★ 3.9 / 5 from 606 reviews

Was Christopher Graham at Matthew's On Main St a mag?
Staff was great and food was awesome. We had the special smoked trout blt and chinease dumpling soup, it was amazing. Wish we had ordered a larger order, so go for the big bowl! The dive style bar in front of the restaurant is fun too. Sit down and have a beer if you have the afternoon or evening free! View all feedback.

maureen-79
Maureen 18.07.2023 - 09:35

Great American dining experience! The variety of food is impressive, and everything is always fresh. It's definitely one of my favorite restaurants in Sullivan County.

lexie-11
Lexie 18.07.2023 - 09:35

The food here is fantastic! The service is incredibly attentive, always checking in to ensure we're satisfied and informing us about all the options available, which are plentiful! You can choose to sit at the bar, in the dining area, or enjoy the outdoor seating. It’s a great spot to watch the game with a beer. They also offer a lovely setting for family brunches and have ample space for large birthday celebrations and work holiday parties. It's an amazing place that you simply must visit!

dilipkumar
Dilipkumar 18.07.2023 - 09:35

Best Restaurants in this small town. They have best salmon fish. I eat fish all the time, but nothing like this one. Also they have all other delicious dishes and different kinds of drinks.

lisa-543
Lisa 18.07.2023 - 09:35

Service was excellent. The food was excellent!

joan-103
joan 18.07.2023 - 09:35

Matthew is the chef and his wide Dominique works the floor. Food is creative and tasty. Ambience is warm and friendly. The bar is separate from the tables. Always enjoy our meals there.

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.