Tailgaters - Caledonia

#11 - Mexican - Caledonia, #17 - Pizza - Caledonia, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Tailgaters

Tailgaters
4.3 / 5 (1325 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Tailgaters from Caledonia comprises about 123 different dishes and drinks. On average you pay about $15.5 for a dish / drink.

Tailgaters Bar Grill, located in Caledonia, WI, is a beloved American restaurant known for its inviting atmosphere and an impressive average rating of 4.4 stars. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 2:00 AM, it’s the perfect spot for both intimate dinners and lively celebrations. To ensure you get a table, call ahead at (262) 732-4259. If you prefer a cozy night in, enjoy their delicious offerings delivered right to your doorstep through Uber Eats or DoorDash. With a great selection of beers to complement your meal, Tailgaters Bar Grill promises a memorable dining experience. If you're looking for similar options, don’t miss Wok N Roll and Hushers Pub Grill. Have you been here before? We’d love to hear your thoughts in a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Debora

Images

Tailgaters Food Tailgaters Food Tailgaters Food Tailgaters Food Tailgaters Logo Tailgaters Inside Tailgaters Food Tailgaters Food

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 1325 reviews

Was Billy at Tailgaters a mag?
I dropped by Tailgaters during their Taco Tuesday special and was very impressed. The food was delicious, they had a great variety of beers, and the waitress was incredibly friendly. I’ll definitely return! Service: Dine-in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dish: Tacos View all feedback.

What Ed Deutsch dislikes about Tailgaters:
Stop here with my son for something to eat. Waited for ever to be served. Waitress brought our waters and the was the last. Never asked us for refills which was bad. Ordered the 16? pizza was $12 which each addition was$2.25 each. Order cheese sausage, pepperoni, onions with order of garlic bread. Ordered the spicy cheese curds with Tuscan marinara and ranch. Ordered garlic bread very very salty hard to eat. Pizza wa... View all feedback.

debora-bernal
03.10.2023

The owner Kim Caze is the best. She makes you feel welcome and actually cares about the service and food you received at her place. Whenever I am in the state of Wisconsin, I will drive out of my way just to have the pizza, cheese bread, cod fish fry, large Bravia German style pretzel with the cheese sauce. My drink is a cold German style beer or (1) Long Island ice tea. No worries if you dine by yourself like usually do, the staff and the regulars will share conversation about the Packers, Brewers, Bucks, or other current events.

ed-deutsch
03.10.2023

Stop here with my son for something to eat. Waited for ever to be served. Waitress brought our waters and the was the last. Never asked us for refills which was bad. Ordered the 16? pizza was $12 which each addition was$2.25 each. Order cheese sausage, pepperoni, onions with order of garlic bread. Ordered the spicy cheese curds with Tuscan marinara and ranch. Ordered garlic bread very very salty hard to eat. Pizza was thin crust and was good along with the cheese curds. Service was poor at best which helps with this rating because you go to a place for food and good service

chas-sc
03.10.2023

My wife and I went here last Saturday for lunch. Our server was Kristen L. We've eaten here before and like is has been in the past the food was very good. The service was a little disappointing. We received our food and started to eat. I was waiting for the server to come by and refill my soda. This took what I thought was a long time. Finally my wife got frustrated because of having to wait. She then grabbed my glass and walked to the entrance of the kitchen and had to ask for a refill. This was frustrating enough but when she got there our waitress was standing there on her phone. She didn't even ask how our meal was. When we paid our bill it took a while before she came back. She stopped to do something on her phone before she brought my credit card back. I'll definitely try this resturant again because of the good food hopefully the server will be better.

debora-bernal-1
20.05.2025

The owner Kim Caze is the best. She makes you feel welcome and actually cares about the service and food you received at her place. Whenever I am in the state of Wisconsin, I will drive out of my way just to have the pizza, cheese bread, cod fish fry,large Bravia German style pretzel with the cheese sauce. My drink is a cold German style beer or (1) Long Island ice tea. Noworries if you dine by yourself like usually do, the staff and the regulars will share conversation about the Packers, Brewers,Bucks, or other current events.

ed-deutsch-weed7809
20.05.2025

Stop here with my son for something to eat. Waited for ever to be served. Waitress brought our waters and the was the last. Never asked us for refills which was bad. Ordered the 16? pizza was $12 which each addition was$2.25 each. Order cheese sausage,pepperoni, onions with order of garlic bread. Ordered the spicy cheese curds with Tuscan marinara and ranch. Ordered garlicbread very very salty hard to eat. Pizza was thin crust and was good along with the cheese curds. Service was poor at best whichhelps with this rating because you go to a place for food and good service

  • Entrées

    Brewer Pretzel
    Brewer Pretzel

    Milwaukees #1 voted pretzel served + our delicious beer cheese!

    $14.0
    Team Effort
    Team Effort
    $19.5
  • Salads

    Qb Caesar Salad
    Qb Caesar Salad

    ICEBERG AND ROMAINE LETTUCE TOSSED IN CREAMY CAESAR DRESSING TOPPED WITH GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST; SHREDDED PARMESAN CHEESE AND CROUTONS

    $15.5
  • Burgers & Sandwiches

    Opening Day Hangover Burger
    Opening Day Hangover Burger

    1/2 LBCHAR‐GRILLED BEEF PATTY; MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE ON A TOASTED BUN TOPPED WITH HASHBROWNS; BACON; FRIED EGG; LETTUCE; TOMATO AND ONION

    $18.5
  • Dinners

    Tailgaters Homemade Meatloaf
    Tailgaters Homemade Meatloaf

    HOMEMADE MEATLOAF JUST LIKE MOM USE TO MAKE. SERVED WITH MASHED POTATOES.

    $17.0

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.