Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute FeedbackIn the vibrant culinary landscape of Caldwell, one pizza place is drawing mixed reviews. While some patrons express frustration over incorrect orders, undercooked pizzas, and long wait times, others sing its praises for outstanding quality and service. Loyal customers appreciate the consistently polite staff and timely deliveries. Visitors from out of town rave about the delicious New Yorker pizza and standout cheesy bread. With recommendations like the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza, there’s a divide between experiences. Overall, opinions range widely, making it a spot of both disappointment and delight for local pizza enthusiasts and newcomers alike.
Was staying in Caldwell for a softball tourney and Plus 1 was recommended by the staff at our hotel. I'm pretty picky with my food but I thought what the hell...and so glad I did!! Amazing pizza, quick delivery and the delivery gal was such a sweetheart!! Highly recommend the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza!!
Was staying in Caldwell for a softball tourney and Plus 1 was recommended by the staff at our hotel. I'm pretty picky with my food but I thought what the hell...and so glad I did!! Amazing pizza, quick delivery and the delivery gal was such a sweetheart!! Highly recommend the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza!!
Ordered plus one pizza tonight. Very good, the service was excellent. Logan made my pizza and I highly recommend her cooking skills.
Don’t rant ever but waiting a hour for 2 pizzas and a couple subs!!! Absolutely crazy. Was told it would be ready at 6:35 and it’s 7:15 and still not done!!
I ordered and took almost 2 hours and food was awful, sloppy and thrown together. Sub was soggy and gross. Not sure what they did but it is usually great
Full Menu
Chicken
Salads
Mexican-American Food
Vegetarian Subs
More information
QR-code link to the menu
