Wagon Wheel Grill - Buffalo

American, Grill, Sandwiches

Wagon Wheel Grill

Wagon Wheel Grill
4.3 / 5 (88 reviews)

Description

Nestled near Lake Seneca, this restaurant promises a diverse selection of dishes at an affordable price, appealing to food lovers and casual diners alike. Patrons rave about the inviting atmosphere, complete with a lovely terrace and excellent service, scoring high on hospitality. However, some have noted inconsistencies in food quality and menu availability, occasionally leaving diners disappointed. The vibe can be mixed, with some finding the clientele less to their taste. Despite these quirks, the establishment remains a cozy local gem, perfect for relaxation and enjoying a hearty meal, including must-try fish and chips and grilled cheese sandwiches.

Last update: 12.07.2026 from: BOSS

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 88 reviews
boss
28.10.2023

The atmosphere is great, the band is fantastic, and there's a lovely outdoor area to relax in.

chazzy-roberts
28.10.2023

Dining Experience: Lunch Average Cost per Person: $10–20 Must-Try Dishes: Fish and Chips, Grilled Cheese Parking Availability: Ample parking Parking Amenities: Free parking lot

wesley-wickham
28.10.2023

Wasn't really impressed with the place, we were the only 1s there and service was slow, I got wings and they were tiny and crunchy Food: 2 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 2

amy-moffitt
28.10.2023

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4

jim-b-tree9
28.10.2023

Tried to order two different items from the menu only to be told they didn't have them. One item they didn't have because of covid 19, really, come on. It's time to quit blaming the lack of odering supplies for your menu on covid 19. Finally, order a fish sandwich only to have them come out and tell me they don't have the bun it normally comes on, and ask if I want bread or a different bun. So they bring me a large piece of fish on a small hamburger bun. When my wifes food arrives, it's barely warm. My sandwich comes with potato chips and a pickle spear. They act like they didn't know this, tgey bring me pickle chips instead and a bag of potato chips. As I'm starting to eat the potato chips, that's when I notice mice have eaten a hole into the bag. The place is terrible.

FAQ

The premises in the restaurant are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.