Tomatoes Pizza - Buffalo

Fish dinner is the best I've had in buffalo in a long time. Definitely will order again. And the young man was very nice. read more Fish dinner is the best I've had in buffalo in a long time. Definitely will order again. And the young man was very nice.

There food is so good I love it they clean nice and affordable read more There food is so good I love it they clean nice and affordable

The only other 2 reviews can't possibly be legitimate, unless I ordered on the most off day any pizzeria has had in all of history. I'm a pizza purist and order... read more The only other 2 reviews can't possibly be legitimate, unless I ordered on the most off day any pizzeria has had in all of history. I'm a pizza purist and ordered cheese and pep pizza, and hot wings. What I received was inedible, this isn't an embellishment. The pizza dough (if you could call it dough), was seemingly of high school cafeteria quality no rise, incredibly cakey, completely devoid of flavor. The cheese was sparse, barely covering the over sauced dough, and maybe 3 4 pepperoni per slice (laughable). Now the wings: slippery, gummy, and undercooked (the only one I bit into was still pinkish inside. Wings should be crispy with good sauce adherence. This order was, at best, f*cking disgusting.

Only had fries and they was not made right read more Only had fries and they was not made right

Walked in here today because every other pizza joint had a 1 hour wait, and I was expecting to get an average tasting pizza due to the price being so low. Man w... read more Walked in here today because every other pizza joint had a 1 hour wait, and I was expecting to get an average tasting pizza due to the price being so low. Man were my expectations blown out of the park. I Felt like a thief buying a pizza that delicious for only 10$, and it was massive. According to the owner, the dough is handmade by him and you can really taste the passion that he puts into his craft. Great food, great owner, and I will for sure be coming back again to taste the rest of their diverse menu.