Santasiero's - Buffalo

#37 - Vegetarian - Fort Erie, Italian, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Santasiero's.

Santasiero's

Santasiero's
3.7 / 5 (1713 reviews)

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Santasiero's from Buffalo featuring all 133 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Santasiero's Restaurant offers classic Italian cuisine in a casual and welcoming setting in Buffalo. Start your meal with homemade garlic bread and a cup of Italian wedding soup. Some popular dishes include pasta specialties like pasta di manzo goulash, stuffed shells, and spaghetti and meatballs. You can also customize your own pasta by choosing from a variety of special sauces. Other delicious options include sandwiches like the Italian sausage bomber, breaded eggplant parmigiana, and roast beef on weck with gravy. Santasiero's Restaurant prides itself on serving great food in a no-frills environment.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: J

Images

Santasiero's Food Santasiero's Food Santasiero's Outside Santasiero's Drink Santasiero's Menu Santasiero's Food Santasiero's Food Santasiero's Food

Reservation request for Santasiero's

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 3.7 / 5 from 1713 reviews

Was Anonym at Santasiero's a mag?
this is a must stop twice in year when I visit family here in buffalo! I've been eating here for over 30 years and eating is just as I remember it from then. service is excellent! the waitress/students are very attentive and informative the portions are plentiful and there is a nice selection of authentic Italian cuisine. I will continue to dinate here when in the city. thanks santasiero’s! View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about Santasiero's:
I was going to give them five stars initially. The service was great and the food was really good. It’s a cool little restaurant! I brought my chicken parmesan leftovers home to have the next day. Unfortunately, when I cut into it and looked a little closer, I noticed that they use processed chicken which is very sub-par and not good for you. Hopefully they’ll return to actual chicken one day. View all feedback.

This is a must stop twice in year when I visit family here in buffalo! I've been eating here for over 30 years and eating is just as I remember it from then. service is excellent! the waitress/students are very attentive and informative the portions are plentiful and there is a nice selection of authentic Italian cuisine. I will continue to dinate here when in the city. thanks santasiero’s!

The real deal! over 100 years long sounding pasta. really great family, super great eating.

A friend was invited here today, who was regular for half a century. because the place proudly stands out with its spaghetti, I ordered a full size and two meatballs (the latter is sold separately) it was served less than 5 minutes later. in the first taste one will not notice anything special and would be only average. the same applies to the meat balls. but as they continue to eat spaghetti and the sauce and later mix with the meatballs, the Umami sensation begins to kick and they want more of it. I do not think it is the best out there, but it is a unique experience and satisfying overall.

j-t-crumb
22.09.2023

I went to Santasiero’s this past Thursday. It pains me to say I’ll never be back. We walked in and noticed a “reservations only” sign on the door. The ignorant waitress asked us aggressively if had reservations, we said no, she said it would be a 2-3 hour wait. Their was hardly anyone sitting in the dining room. The ambience was never great but now it’s become an actual filthy hole. I had fond memories of going to Santasiero’s for years but I can honestly say those days are done. Disgusting!

paula-churchill
22.09.2023

Santasiero's is now take out only. Not happy. Food is delicious just like when I used to go down after work and have a sit down dinner.The reason I gave them a 4 star rating is because of the food and service.Parking: You shouldn't have a problem parking now with only take out service.

  • Pasta Dishes

    Pasta Fasoola
    Pasta Fasoola
    $9.0
    Peas & Macaroni
    Peas & Macaroni
    $9.0
    Lentils & Macaroni
    Lentils & Macaroni
    $12.3
  • White Wines

    House Chardonnay
    House Chardonnay
    $4.8
  • These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served

  • Breakfast

    Full Half
    Full Half

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.