Niagara Cafe - Buffalo

#38 - Order Seafood Buffalo, Cafe, Latin-american
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Niagara Cafe

Niagara Cafe
4.3 / 5 (8175 reviews)

Menu

A complete overview of all 54 meals and beverages can be found here on the menu of Niagara Cafe from Buffalo.

**Delight or Disappointment: A Culinary Tale at Niagara Cafe** Niagara Cafe, a cherished local destination for authentic Puerto Rican cuisine, offers a vibrant dining experience that evokes deep cultural appreciation. Dishes like rotisserie chicken, pastellillos, and beans consistently garner rave reviews for their rich flavors and generous portions. Many patrons express deep affection for the welcoming atmosphere and friendly service. However, some have voiced concerns over rising prices and diminished portion sizes, sparking debates about consistency. Despite a few criticisms, Niagara Cafe remains a beloved fixture, ideal for those seeking a hearty meal steeped in culinary tradition, giving diners the chance to indulge and enjoy.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: James

Images

Niagara Cafe Food Niagara Cafe Food Niagara Cafe Food Niagara Cafe Food Niagara Cafe Menu Niagara Cafe Menu Niagara Cafe Drink Niagara Cafe Menu

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 8175 reviews

Was Jeffrey Gardella at Niagara Cafe a mag?
*This business is cash only* They do have an ATM inside It's a busy inner-city local favorite with authentic Puerto Rican food. They have a small eat-in area and a takeout counter for quick pick-up. Lunchtime gets very busy so I'd suggest looking at the menu before walking in. The portions are large and everything I've ever gotten has been delicious. It's a must try if you haven't already.

What Kathy Phillips dislikes about Niagara Cafe:
I have them one more chance today...they disappointed me again and for the last time...im ordered 4 pastellios.hard...hardly any filling...pitatoes were very small compared to what I had got in past...prices have increased...and quality had gone down...will be going to competition across the street...spent over 40 dollars...never again View all feedback.

janie-11
17.08.2023

The food was absolutely delicious! We ordered pastelillos, sweet plantains, and alcapurria, and everything was 100% fantastic. It was so good that I completely forgot to take pictures before we finished it all!

fernando-1767
17.08.2023

The food is delicious, served fresh, and the prices are reasonable for the quality. I believe this restaurant is a must-visit if you're in Buffalo.

marcia-317
17.08.2023

The food is truly delicious, and the customer service is outstanding. It's definitely worth waiting in line to place your order, pay, and savor the meal.

james-bill-blackknig
17.08.2024

Absolutely! Every time I'm in Buffalo, I make sure to stop by and eat here!

demetrius-foster
17.08.2024

Pastelillos and parcha.... sick for 3 days.

  • Classic Burgers

    Famous Rallis Burger
    Famous Rallis Burger
    8 Oz. Banquet Burger
    8 Oz. Banquet Burger
  • Kids Menu (12 & Under)

    Chicken Fingers (2 Fingers & Fries)
    Chicken Fingers (2 Fingers & Fries)
    Chicken Nuggets (4 Nuggets & Fries)
    Chicken Nuggets (4 Nuggets & Fries)
  • Breakfast & Others

    Egg, Ham & Egg
    Egg, Ham & Egg
  • Sides

    Onion Rings - Homemade
    Onion Rings - Homemade

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.