Arty's Grill - Buffalo

Grill, American, Pubs

Arty's Grill

★ 4.1 / 5 (476 reviews)

**Dining Experience Review: Arty's Tavern** Nestled in the historic Polonia section of Buffalo's East Side, Arty's Tavern offers a glimpse into a bygone era with its old-fashioned charm and friendly service. While many cherish its affordability and lively atmosphere, some patrons have encountered issues, from unexpected cash-only policies to unsatisfactory interactions with staff. Nevertheless, the tavern remains a popular gathering spot for locals, especially during festive occasions like Dyngus Day. With generous sandwiches and reasonably priced drinks, Arty's serves as a nostalgic retreat for those seeking both warmth and camaraderie in a city rich with history.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Bill

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 476 reviews

Was ECWA Plarr at Arty's Grill a mag?
I've known about Arty's for a long time but never had the opportunity to visit. It was exactly as I imagined. The tavern has an old-fashioned charm, with friendly service and affordable prices. If you’re on Buffalo's East Side, be sure to step back in time and pay a visit to Arty's! View all feedback.

What Harmon Konopelski dislikes about Arty's Grill:
As a patriotic Buffalonian it pains me to write a bad review of one of the last remaining taverns in the historic Polonia section of the east side, but here goes... The food is remarkably unremarkable. The place doesn't accept cards as payment, they don't bother telling you this before you order and to my knowledge there isn't any sign to indicate this. They apparently don't charge sales tax (kind of a wink wink situ... View all feedback.

Barbara

17.12.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The food was fantastic, and the staff were incredible. This is the best dining and customer service experience I've ever had in Buffalo. Sincerely, Barbara.

Manda

17.12.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

I may have only visited on Dyngus Day, but it just wouldn't be the same celebration without Arty's!

matthew

17.12.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

I visit this place annually to celebrate Dyngus Day with my fellow Polish friends. We enjoy drinking beer, having a great time, and embracing the weather, whether it's nice or not! Beer always makes the weather more enjoyable!