Williamsburg Pizza - Brooklyn

They claim that NYC has the best pizza, and Williamsburg Pizza definitely proves that point! The crust is fantastic, and the slices are delicious and juicy. Whether you choose to dine in or take out, the quality is consistently excellent!

I arrived close to closing time, so it wasn’t too crowded. I was greeted right away and placed my order for a Grandma's pie and a regular slice. They were surprisingly quick, and I left excited to try my slices at home. Initially, I considered dining in, but it didn't seem like the best atmosphere for enjoying the food—though I should note that I came in near closing on a weekday, so that might not be representative of the overall vibe. As for the pizza itself, it was delicious: - Cheese pull? Check. - Firm crust with just the right amount of flop? Check. - Not overly greasy but bursting with flavor? Double check. - Chewy and soft interior dough? Check. This place exceeded my already high standards for New York slices, which is really impressive!

Came here for a late night meal and I was a bit dissapointed. I had high hopes going in, having heard of this place before. The prices of pizza by the slice don't justify the flavor, which was lacking. I got Tartufo, Bianco, and Paesano slices. They all looked great and were not the common pizzas having fresh and appetizing ingredients. Sorry to say they all lacked flavor, they were good just not something I would spend money on again. I was very excited for the meatball hero and it tasted very fresh, but again, bland. Didn't even have much saltiness to it, especially compared to some pizza slices. Overall I guess it's a nice spot if you have no other options after a bar, but not a go to during the day.

Williamsburg Pizza has the perfect sauce to cheese ratio! Love this place for a perfect plain slice!

I'm not sure why this place has received some negative reviews. I've been here a few times, and the pizza is genuinely excellent. It has a very fresh taste—neither too oily nor overly seasoned—so you really feel like you're getting your money's worth. I always order the margherita and grandma slices, and they are absolutely delicious! The flavors are authentic, and the pepperoni and other ingredients are very fresh. The restaurant has plenty of tables for dining in, but during my last visit, it was completely full, which was disappointing. There was outdoor seating available, but it was too cold for that, so I decided to order takeout instead. You can also stand by the window to eat, but that feels a bit strange, so takeout was the best option for me. They have condiments like cheese and pepper readily available, which is a nice touch!