The Commodore - Brooklyn

Casual, Chicken, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for The Commodore.

The Commodore

The Commodore
4.2 / 5 (3595 reviews)

Menu

The place from Brooklyn offers 118 different courses and drinks on the menu at an average price of $9.9.

Nestled in a vibrant spot, this restaurant offers a lively atmosphere and a tempting menu that includes standout dishes like fried chicken, burgers, and nachos. While many patrons rave about the delicious food and fun pirate-themed decor, a few experiences fell short due to service inconsistencies, such as long waits and mix-ups. The beverage selection received mixed reviews, with some drinks not meeting expectations. Overall, the establishment shines with its flavorful offerings and welcoming environment, making it a worthwhile visit for friends looking to enjoy great bar food, despite minor service hiccups.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Brandon

Images

The Commodore Food The Commodore Food The Commodore Food The Commodore Menu The Commodore Menu The Commodore Food The Commodore Food The Commodore Food

Reservation request for The Commodore

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 3595 reviews

Was User at The Commodore a mag?
The food was surprisingly excellent. The apple sauce with a touch of honey makes for a very creative and delicious dipping sauce. The kitchen stays open late and provides top-notch quality even at 1 AM! View all feedback.

What User dislikes about The Commodore:
Super rude bartenders, especially the men working there. They won't even look at you across the bar unless you're a pretty white girl. I could tell from who they were selectively grabbing orders from. 2 stars just for the decent late night food. View all feedback.

fronimakis-anastasia-2
06.02.2024

The fried chicken lives up to all the hype – it’s incredibly delicious. The cheeseburger, hot chicken sandwich, and nachos are all outstanding as well. In fact, it’s the best burger in town! The atmosphere is relaxed and easygoing, and they offer a great selection of affordable beers. I can't wait to return!

kris
06.02.2024

Best chicken sandwich in the city... Or anywhere. Highly recommend!

feng-li-1
06.02.2024

We came here on a Sunday night around peak dinner time and were able to get a table. It’s self seating and you’ll have to order at the bar but service is quick and the food is even better. The fried chicken plate is a gem. Definitely some of the best fried chicken you can get in NYC. The last time we had it was almost a half a decade ago and it was still as amazing as the first time. Perfectly fried and all meat, barely any bone which was surprising and highly appreciated. The tuna melt was also fantastic, mixed with both red and white onion. The kale Caesar was slightly on the salty side but made a refreshing break between the fried chicken. Fries are fries, portion was huge. We spent about $70 dollars including tip for everything. Great place with even greater food! Would recommend.

brandon-w-weed8458
04.11.2025

Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Meal type: Other Price per person: $10–20

jordanh
15.04.2024

I will always love this place, but my tuna melt had cold sliced cheese on it, which was a bit surprising!

  • Chef's Specials

    Spicy Veggie-Burger Tacos (3)
    Spicy Veggie-Burger Tacos (3)
    $12.1
    Shrimp Boy Sandwich
    Shrimp Boy Sandwich
    $11.1
  • Sandwiches

    Hot Breast (Or Medium)
    Hot Breast (Or Medium)
    $13.2
    Mild Breast
    Mild Breast
    $13.2
  • Sides, Snacks & Stuff

    Stewed Blackeyed Peas
    Stewed Blackeyed Peas
    $9.1
  • Brunchies

    Commodore Plate*
    Commodore Plate*
    $12.1

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.