Sal Paul's Pizzeria - Brooklyn

Italian, Pizza, Salads
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Sal Paul's Pizzeria

Sal Paul's Pizzeria
4.4 / 5 (2655 reviews)

Menu

The restaurant from Brooklyn offers 72 different courses and drinks on the menu for an average price of $12.5.

Nestled in the neighborhood, this beloved pizza shop has earned a reputation for its delicious, chewy crusts and friendly service. Diners rave about the legendary garlic knots and a variety of toppings, showcasing a commitment to quality and community. The polite staff ensures an enjoyable experience, although some patrons have raised concerns about hygiene practices, particularly regarding glove usage while handling food. Despite these issues, the restaurant's nostalgic charm and delectable pizza continue to draw a loyal following, making it a cherished local gem. Overall, it's a spot worth visiting for both a slice and a warm welcome.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Aya

Images

Sal Paul's Pizzeria Food Sal Paul's Pizzeria Food Sal Paul's Pizzeria Food Sal Paul's Pizzeria Food Sal Paul's Pizzeria Food Sal Paul's Pizzeria Food Sal Paul's Pizzeria Food Sal Paul's Pizzeria Food

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 2655 reviews

Was D K at Sal Paul's Pizzeria a mag?
I just had a slice of Sicilian, he even asked if I wanted from the middle or a corner. It was pretty good, I was pleasantly surprised, I wasn't thinking I get an old school slice on Pitkin? View all feedback.

lennys-negron
14.01.2024

I absolutely adore the pizza crust at this restaurant. The service is consistently excellent as well. My only gripe is that they close early because of their location.

stephanie-nicole-wee-1
14.01.2024

The best pizza I have ever had in Brownsville and the kids love the colorful slushies.

canela
14.01.2024

I absolutely loved my pizza from this restaurant. I can't stop thinking about it and I plan on returning when I'm in Brooklyn next. The prices are average, with no lunch specials but they do have a slushy fountain available.

aya-s-tree72
13.01.2024

The pizza is always so good and delicious, as you can see I started eating it before i remembered to snap a pic. The Pasta with Alfredo Sauce Grilled Chicken is too saucy and seems very generic with soupy white sauce and bland chicken. The salad is just a bital salad nothing really too special but the portion size is great.

shontia-g
13.01.2024

Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza Buffalo Wings Garlic Knots Zeppole were magnificently Delicious same Great Taste every time I apos;ve been eating from Sal apos;s Paul for over 20years

  • Pizza

    Baby Deep Dish Pizza
    Baby Deep Dish Pizza
    $6.5
    Buffalo Style Chicken Pizza
    Buffalo Style Chicken Pizza

    Deep dish style + cubed chicken breast in a home‐made buffalo style sauce topped + Mozzarella & Bleu cheese.

    $26.2
  • Heroes

    Bacon Cheese Ranch Hero
    Bacon Cheese Ranch Hero

    Grilled chicken + bacon topped + ranch dressing.

    $13.1
    Fried Chicken Cutlet Hero
    Fried Chicken Cutlet Hero
    $10.6
  • Pasta

    Pasta With Alfredo Sauce Grilled Chicken
    Pasta With Alfredo Sauce Grilled Chicken

    Choice of pasta + home‐made alfredo sauce topped + grilled chicken.

    $15.1
  • Rolls & Calzones

    Sausage Parm Roll
    Sausage Parm Roll
    $8.6

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.