Reviews - OTB
Reviews summary
Despite receiving mixed reviews on service quality and reservation process, this Williamsburg bar seems to have a lot going for it. Reviewers agree that the drinks and food are great, with a nice selection and delicious options. The ambiance is comfortable, and the staff, while hit or miss in some cases, are described as attentive and friendly. The bar is popular among visitors who appreciate being recognized and well-served by the staff. Despite some minor setbacks in service, the overall experience seems positive and invites repeat visits. It is considered a gem in the Williamsburg neighborhood, offering a relaxed and enjoyable atmosphere for a night out with friends or family.
Was Cathy D at OTB a mag?
My new favorite bar in the winter because there's so much natural light during the daytime. And there are tasty warm winter beverages in adorable mugs. The little things make a difference during these gloomy winter months. The staff were so accommodating for my party of 25. I made the reservations two weeks in advance and everything worked out perfectly. I am so grateful to OTB. This place is right on the way to the... View all feedback.
What Viola Gerhold dislikes about OTB:
I tried to call a few times during their business hours and the phone would just ring and ring and no one picked up - not sure if they even set up a phone. When I came up for this special birthday party, I planned that they didn't even know I made a reservation. to round it off, our waitress was rude and pretended that she could not even serve us. When the scare came, she gave us her lipstick to sign because she had... View all feedback.
Images uploaded by reviewers
Reviews from various users
Last update : 14.10.2025
Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
We had the best time ever!!!! Came here for our anniversary drinks and the bartender whipped up super special surprises. Very well made drinks and incredible service and decor. Thank you OTB. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
I loved this bar. The aesthetics are beautiful. The service is amazing. Russell, the bartender, is wonderful. The have a pool table. Happy Hour has great deals which include some food items, such as 1/2 dozen oysters for $9. The oysters taste fresh. I have to checkout their $10 Happy Hour Cheeseburger. The Cocktails are good. The people that came in were very nice. They also have good music. I will definitely be back. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Price per person: $50–100
Last update : 14.01.2024
The restaurant had a fantastic ambiance and the drinks were good. We stopped by on a Sunday afternoon and it wasn't too crowded. We ordered Hot Toddys and Margaritas along with a side of fries. I thought the portion of fries was a bit small, but I really enjoyed the Hot Toddys - they were not too sweet and had a nice lemony flavor.
I have visited many bars in NYC, but this one stands out as one of the best. The staff is exceptional, the atmosphere is perfect, and the drinks are fantastic. They treated me and 30 of my friends so well for my birthday celebration. Thank you for a truly memorable night!
Amazing drinks, delicious comfort food. The place has a relaxed vibe that’s welcoming any time of day or night. Has a large bar, multiple booths, a pool table, and outdoor seating. The staff is great and the owner is a total badass with a wealth of knowledge of cocktails and spirits. I’ve been coming for years and I absolutely love this place!
The bar was fantastic, the service was great, and the atmosphere was absolutely amazing.
Cocktails are very mediocre and sweet. Oysters are good but I don't recommend the wings very dry
Last update : 21.08.2023
Very cozy and cool place to visit with family or friends. We came there for a drink, to relax after a long week. Moscow Mule was excellent! The next day we came back for oysters. They were just amazing! The staff is very friendly and they recognized us right away which means they pay attention to their customers We are definitely planning to visit this place again when we will travel to Brooklyn again.
This is the first time I have been in Brooklyn and decided to take a chance on a small restaurant. Pretty freaking amazing. The salad is delicious, the burger is home cooked and the fries are cooked just right. 10 stars out of 5. Keep it up guys!Food: 5/5
Their simple menu of Americana/French classics shines. Affordable and fun this bistro strums a note in between American dive and casual bistro. The sauce burger was excellent (get it medium).
Solid gem of a casual spot for drinks
I stopped by here before a show and the set up is cute. They had nice music playing but it wasn't too loud. The waiter Nesto was super friendly and attentive, service was 10/10. Would def recommend stopping by.
Last update : 26.04.2023
I tried to call a few times during their business hours and the phone would just ring and ring and no one picked up – not sure if they even set up a phone. When I showed up for this special birthday party, I planned that they didn't even know I made a reservation. To round it off, our waitress was rude and acted as if she could not even serve us. When the check came, she gave us her lipstick to sign because she had no pen.... It's a nice bar, with good drinks, but as usual in Williamsburg.
As always great food and a good time. Grilled wings are some of the best in town. With her cocktails, great.
I tried to call a few times during their business hours and the phone would just ring and ring and no one picked up - not sure if they even set up a phone. When I came up for this special birthday party, I planned that they didn't even know I made a reservation. to round it off, our waitress was rude and pretended that she could not even serve us. When the scare came, she gave us her lipstick to sign because she had no pencil. it is a nice bar, with good drinks, but as usual overpriced in williamsburg.
As always great eating and a good time. grilling wings are some of the best in the city. with her cocktails, great.
The food was very good. A little pricey but the service was excellent. Unfortunately there was a private party going on so we had to sit downstairs in the bar area. Next time I would like to sit in the regular dining area or out on the beautiful patio.
