Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe:
the bagels are great with a very nice sort. However, what keeps me from giving 5 stars is sometimes the server rude to ask me several times for my ticket if I have just paid for my food or time when they have a limited amount of bagels. View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe:
There were signs inside the store, that due to a shortage of cream cheese they are low on flavors.Ordered an egg bagel with olive cream cheese and the amount of cream cheese they put is a joke and they charged $4.50 for it. Terrible business practice. It was like eating a bagel with nothing on it. Will not recommend. View all feedback.
I stopped by this place to get a lox bagel and really enjoyed it. I had an everything bagel which was perfectly soft on the inside yet crunchy on the outside. The lox and accompanying cream cheese and veggies weee also delicious. I’d come back here to pick up bagels again
The bagels were not fresh and the cream cheese was too cold and not whipped. They have a variety of unique cream cheese flavors to choose from, including horseradish dill, sundried tomato, and Chipotle, which were all enjoyable.
I’m the past the gluten-free bagels here were almost mini pizza-bagel sized, but it appears they have started making them bigger! That being said, it wasn’t cheap, but a nice treat!I had been going to another place because theirs were normal sized, but decided to stop in today because I was craving their sun-dried tomato, tofu cream cheese.I was happily surprised to see the size today! Texture was also very close to the classic New York (glutenous) bagels we all know and love (which I can’t eat anymore). This one today was tasty and nostalgic. The everything seasoning reminded me of childhood.I make my breakfast most days, but I will start coming back here more often if they keep it up!
I ordered the Zatar and Feta bagel with egg and it was amazing. The bagel was delicious and freshly made.
Too in love to snap a photo first!! Best bagel I’ve had in my life! I had it with the Mexican Tuna Salad (don’t order if you don’t like spice!! . Had it on an everything bagel. 10/10. Can’t wait to go back!