Nonno's Pizza - Brooklyn

I don't understand how a grandma slice can smell so good, given all the ingredients, yet taste completely bland. I tried adding my own seasonings to salvage it, but even then, it was still just crispy cardboard. At nearly $30 for a whole pie, I expected something worthwhile. For some people, $30 represents two hours of work, so that was quite disappointing. The garlic knots, which someone described as "juicy," turned out to be nothing more than oil and grease with a bit of garlic and parsley thrown in. The only redeeming aspect was the chicken soup, which was decent. Unfortunately, I ended up needing a refund. Overall, the experience was unacceptable. You only get one chance to make a first impression, and I won't be ordering from here again.

My favorite pizza place in Bay Ridge! The rice ball special is absolutely amazing and brings back memories of my grandmother's delicious home-cooked Italian meals (and that's a huge compliment!). The chicken Francese is also fantastic. I will definitely be ordering from here again and again!

The service was good, and the restaurant had a nice atmosphere. I tried two different slices of pizza, and both were quite salty. On the plus side, the pizza was definitely fresh. I'll be back.

It's just a simple local spot, mostly focused on delivery, but I have to say, it's hands down the best slice of pizza you'll find within a 2-mile radius.

I appreciate that you let me try the pepperoni pizza and the cheese pizza, even though I only ordered the pepperoni. However, next time, I would prefer just the pepperoni. That said, it was delicious!