Hamilton's Brooklyn

American, American Restaurant,, Casual
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Hamilton's Brooklyn.

Hamilton's Brooklyn

Hamilton's Brooklyn
4.1 / 5 (759 reviews)

Description

**Dining Experience at Local Gem: A Blend of Delight and Disappointment**

This neighborhood restaurant offers a mixed bag of dining experiences. While some patrons praise its welcoming atmosphere and outdoor seating, others report cleanliness issues and lackluster service. Despite a few standout dishes, such as juicy burgers and well-prepared brunch items, numerous complaints highlight the unappetizing quality of several meals, including poorly executed huevos rancheros and greasy sandwiches. Service has been inconsistent, with reports of long waits and inattentive staff. While there are glimpses of potential, diners are advised to tread cautiously, balancing their expectations against the diverse reviews.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: AJ

Reservation request for Hamilton's Brooklyn

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 759 reviews
jenn-180
08.08.2023

I would rate this restaurant zero stars if I could. The food was inedible. Who wants horseradish-flavored eggs? That’s what you end up with when they throw a literal salad on top of them. What genius decided that a salad belongs with breakfast? Their "homestyle country gravy with sausage" was essentially just a roux with pork added, which is why it had an orange tint. It was unappetizing. The eggs were repulsive. And as for the "fresh juice"... it was just a small can of pineapple juice, which they charge $4 for! DO NOT EAT HERE. They must be paying for reviews because there’s no way this place deserves a 4/5 star rating. It’s simply disgusting.

kazi-22
08.08.2023

Never got my food. Waited 15 minutes after being seated to be told power is going down (what? and that we would have to wait another 30 minutes to order hot food. Multiple people including the guy at the bar and the guy who sat us saw us seated for over 15 minutes without notifying us.Food: 1/5

argjila
08.08.2023

The restaurant was absolutely filthy. It used to be a place where my family and I genuinely enjoyed our meals, but this time we found what looked like a hairball hidden beneath our salads. As for the service, the staff seemed completely oblivious to their responsibilities. When we mentioned the hair, they showed no concern whatsoever. Instead, they offered my son a plate of wedges "on the house," and then had the audacity to charge us for the contaminated food.

aj-l-2
06.03.2024

I visited this restaurant with friends after completing a half-marathon, and we had a wonderful experience. We were promptly seated in a beautifully decorated outdoor area. We decided to share a flight...

alaina-p-church5
06.03.2024

The food is decent, but the service is quite poor. I've had several lackluster experiences over the years, but today was the worst, and I’ve decided to stop trying.

Menu

  • Breakfast/Brunch

    Two Organic Eggs Any Style With Griddle Potatoes
    Two Organic Eggs Any Style With Griddle Potatoes
    $11.5
  • Sandwiches

    Parmesan Crusted Grilled Cheese Tomato
    Parmesan Crusted Grilled Cheese Tomato
    $12.5
    Grilled Portobello Mushroom Served With Salad Or Potato Wedges
    Grilled Portobello Mushroom Served With Salad Or Potato Wedges
    $14.6
    The Ella Fitzgerald Sandwich
    The Ella Fitzgerald Sandwich
    $15.1
    Salmon Cod Cake Burger
    Salmon Cod Cake Burger
    $17.1
  • Salads &Amp; Small Plates

    Pan Seared Salmon Cod Cake
    Pan Seared Salmon Cod Cake
    $15.1

FAQ

A little farther located is MTA-Church Ave-F Line, where you can also access the public transportation.

The restaurant offers free WiFi for its guests.

There is a TV / screen on-site where sporting events are shown.

The diner and its rooms are wheelchair accessible and thus usable with a wheelchair or physiological disabilities.

The restaurant also takes the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.