Hail Mary - Brooklyn

American, Diners, Desserts
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Hail Mary

Hail Mary
3.9 / 5 (158 reviews)

Description

Nestled in Greenpoint, this restaurant boasts a charming atmosphere and an intriguing menu that captivates diners. Many highlight the delicious dishes, particularly the mac and cheese and roasted burrata, alongside creative cocktails that elevate the dining experience. However, inconsistency in service and music volume detracts from the enjoyment. Some guests encountered issues with cold food and inattentive staff, while the loud, mismatched soundtrack turned a cozy ambiance jarring. Despite these flaws, for some, the whimsical concept and delightful desserts prove a worthy draw, making it a memorable stop before a night out. A place with potential, but room for improvement.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: VanessaB

Feedback

★ 3.9 / 5 from 158 reviews
opentable-3
21.07.2023

Everything was delicious, especially the macaroni and cheese and the fried burrata. The drinks were good, but I wouldn't recommend the cola-flavored soda, as it didn't taste great. However, the waitress was very nice and offered to swap it for a vanilla soda, which was delicious.

opentable-3
21.07.2023

Good food in a charming setting but truly terrible service

lisak
21.07.2023

I traveled to Greenpoint from Manhattan for brunch with a friend. In 22 years on the UES I've never left the borough for a meal. SO WORTH the trip. Great place food was so good, creative cocktails and desserts, fun kitschy concept. I WILL be back. Total gem!

vanessab
21.07.2023

Amazing. lived up to all the hype. the fried chicken, the burrata, the pop tart? wow!

opentable-3
21.07.2023

The service was terrible. It was as though my table did not exist and the restaurant wasn't even crowded. The food was served cold and was very mediocre. I definitely do not recommend this restaurant and I will certainly not be returning.

FAQ

You can also pay for your dishes with the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.