Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute FeedbackGargiulo's in Brooklyn is a historic restaurant known for delicious food and top-notch service. Recently, some diners experienced long wait times and felt the menu was overpriced. Despite this, many patrons have had exceptional experiences, praising the outdoor dining setup, delicious food, and fantastic service. The restaurant has also been lauded for its beautiful Christmas decorations and great desserts. Overall, Gargiulo's remains a popular spot for Italian cuisine in Coney Island, with standout dishes like the New Zealand rack of lamb.
Mom and I had Jerry as our waiter. He knew what we were ordering before we did. He also knew what we wanted to order to take home to eat during the week. Going to Gargiulo's is like Sunday dinner at Grandma's house. The owners stop by to take a seat and talk a while. We feel so loved when we go there.
We had an excellent lunch on Saturday. The service was excellent and so was the atmosphere. This was our first time visiting Coney Island. We will definitely come back and especially eat at Gargiulo's.
Jerry was our waiter and he treated my entire table of 7 guests like family. He knew our wants and needs before we did. All the other waiters stopped by to say hello. When we go there it's like attending a family reunion. We feel the love and warmth as soon as we walk in.
Food was great as always My family has celebrated lots of occasions there Something for everyone
I have been here numerous times, and never have I had any disappointments.
Full Menu
Coffee
Salads
Soups
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
More information
QR-code link to the menu
