Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Michelle A likes about Cropsey Bagels:
Best bagels in NY — hidden gem. Bagels are so fresh, soft and pillowy. All the toppings are great but their lox is next level delicious. As a New Yorker, I’ve tried maaany bagels and this is hands down the best. People who go to bagel boy don’t know what a bagel should actually taste like. Don’t be surprised if there’s a long line ahead of you but it’s well worth the wait. View all feedback.
What Thayra Vasquez doesn't like about Cropsey Bagels:
I ordered 2 deli sandwiches first off they were $35 and they were both wrong. Bread was stale, hard and old. And then I called them and they said “what do you want me to do about it” View all feedback.
Other reviewers have mentioned it, and I agree: the sandwiches are pricey and nothing to write home about. I only visit this place for their bagels. The bagels are fairly priced, and they’re the best I’ve encountered when it comes to bagels.
Attention to detail in food preparation... DELICIOUS!!! The food is fantastic, and the service is excellent!
The service was outstanding, and the atmosphere was incredibly fast-paced. I entered the shop and was in and out in just 3-5 minutes. If there were an option for 10 stars, I'd give it 11!
Egg salad on a bagel and bacon, egg&cheese in a roll from a 20. I left with 3 bucks. My first visit, and no more for me. Nothing extraordinary for the price.
I ordered 2 deli sandwiches first off they were $35 and they were both wrong. Bread was stale, hard and old. And then I called them and they said “what do you want me to do about it”
More information
QR-code link to the menu
