Bella Gioia - Brooklyn

Sicilian, Italian, Mediterranean
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Bella Gioia.

Bella Gioia

Bella Gioia
4.1 / 5 (1037 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Bella Gioia from Brooklyn includes 210 menus. On average the menus or drinks on the menu cost approximately $21.4. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Bella Gioia offers a mixed bag of experiences, with some patrons praising the delicious food, attentive service, and cozy ambiance, while others were left disappointed by subpar dishes and unpleasant encounters with the staff. The restaurant's Italian cuisine seems to have its highs and lows, with some diners raving about dishes like the oxtail ragu Parpadelle and veal piccata, while others found their meals to be lackluster. Despite some mixed reviews, the restaurant's charming setting, warm service, and scenic views seem to have left a positive impression on many diners. Whether you're looking for a romantic date spot or a cozy breakfast spot with a view, Bella Gioia may have something to offer, but be prepared for potentially inconsistent experiences.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Diana

Images

Bella Gioia Food Bella Gioia Food Bella Gioia Food Bella Gioia Food Bella Gioia Food Bella Gioia Drink Bella Gioia Outside Bella Gioia Food

Reservation request for Bella Gioia

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 1037 reviews

Was Sherry D at Bella Gioia a mag?
First, their meat and cheese board is a favorite whenever we have friends over or are in need of some comforting food. The gorgonzola and prosciutto are personal highlights for me. Additionally, their gnocchi dish called Rustica is a standout. Served piping hot on a pan, the gnocchi is a perfect blend of potatoes, tomatoes, and cheese. The servers even warn you to be careful not to burn yourself because it is so fres... View all feedback.

What Diana Zhu dislikes about Bella Gioia:
What a disappointment. We came here to celebrate my boyfriend's birthday. The Italian food we had at this restaurant was some of the worst I've ever had in New York City. My chicken was rubbery and completely inedible, and the sauces were bland and tasteless. View all feedback.

nikolaus-jonathan
01.11.2017

I've been coming to Bella Gioia for a while now and my experiences are always amazingThe food and the service are always excellent.

jarrell-gutmann
01.11.2017

Went here last night with a reservation for a group of 7The interior is rustic and very cozy.

sauer-julius
01.11.2017

Staff was friendly though there was definitely room for improvement.

diana-1322
05.08.2023

What a disappointment. We came here to celebrate my boyfriend's birthday. The Italian food we had at this restaurant was some of the worst I've ever had in New York City. My chicken was rubbery and completely inedible, and the sauces were bland and tasteless.

sherry-8
05.08.2023

First, their meat and cheese board is a favorite whenever we have friends over or are in need of some comforting food. The gorgonzola and prosciutto are personal highlights for me. Additionally, their gnocchi dish called Rustica is a standout. Served piping hot on a pan, the gnocchi is a perfect blend of potatoes, tomatoes, and cheese. The servers even warn you to be careful not to burn yourself because it is so fresh from the kitchen. Overall, Bella Gioia has truly set the bar for Italian cuisine and I can't wait to revisit and indulge in their delicious dishes once again.

  • Pasta * Maccaruna/A Pasta

    Pasta Cu Sarde
    Pasta Cu Sarde
    $21.1
    Risu
    Risu
    $28.1
  • Entrees * I Secunni

    Cotoletto Di Viteddu
    Cotoletto Di Viteddu
    $24.1
    Gaddina Di Casa
    Gaddina Di Casa
    $20.1
    Pisci Spata
    Pisci Spata
    $29.1
  • Dessert

    Gelato Dello Giorno
    Gelato Dello Giorno
    $9.0

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.