Reviews
What John Walsh doesn't like about Bagel Boy:
I use to love this place. Quality of food and service has gone down. Staff aren't friendly at all. The past couple of times purchased food were not put in my bag. I took the loss because I had gotten home already. This last time I made sure to look in the bag before I walked out and of course something was missing. I expressed to the gentleman that runs the store this is not the first time this has happened. He seeme... View all feedback. What John Walsh likes about Bagel Boy:
I wish we lived closer to this restaurant! Our cousins are doing a great job! The place is very clean, has a great selection of deli meats and bagels, and everything tastes excellent. Make sure you don't confuse it with any other Bagel Boy. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel. The bagel was fresh and delicious. This place is one of the best spots for bagels in South Brooklyn....
read moreI wish we lived closer to this restaurant! Our cousins are doing a great job! The place is very clean, has a great selection of deli meats and bagels, and every...
read moreWe have been getting our bagels from this place for a few years now. They never disappoint - their bagels are always fresh and fluffy. They offer a variety of s...
read moreI use to love this place. Quality of food and service has gone down. Staff aren't friendly at all. The past couple of times purchased food were not put in my ba...
read moreEdit: Since posting my review, the quality control has definitely gone down. Multiple times I have received stale bread, incorrect coffee, an incorrect order or...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreBagel Boy has garnered a loyal following for its fresh, fluffy bagels and delicious salads. Many patrons praise the quality and selection, highlighting the delightful bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches that showcase the bakery's expertise. However, recent visits reveal a decline in service and food quality, with reports of incorrect orders, stale bread, and unwelcoming staff. While the atmosphere remains vibrant and the locale clean, some diners are reconsidering their frequent patronage, citing inconsistent experiences. For those seeking reliable breakfast fare, a little due diligence may be necessary before diving into a meal at this once-beloved spot.