Howard's Cafe - Brookhaven
Menu
A comprehensive menu of Howard's Cafe from Brookhaven featuring all 26 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.
**A Mixed Bag at Howard's: A Local Dining Experience** At Howard's, patrons are greeted with a charming, retro ambiance reminiscent of simpler times, offering a diverse menu featuring everything from burgers to hearty comfort food. While many locals appreciate the generous portions and reasonable prices, including complimentary salads and drinks, recent reviews reveal a concerning decline in both food quality and service. Complaints about overcooked dishes, disappointing flavors, and inattentive staff have surfaced, leaving some regulars disillusioned. Though the restaurant has its loyal fans, the inconsistency has prompted others to rethink their dining choices in the area. Overall, it seems Howard's is struggling to maintain its once-stellar reputation.
Images
Feedback
Was Tanya L at Howard's Cafe a mag?
I discovered this hidden gem while off the beaten path. The steak sandwich was outstanding, and the teriyaki chicken was just as delicious. Their cheeseburgers are amazing, and they have the best mozzarella sticks I’ve ever had! Every meal comes with a salad, which is a nice touch. The prices are unbeatable, and I can’t recommend this place enough! Oh, and I was thrilled to find High Noon for just $3.50! View all feedback.
What Robert D dislikes about Howard's Cafe:
I entered and was seated pretty promptly with my party. We were given menus and never had a waitress come to the table. Five waitresses stood around the station talking for the majority of the time we sat there. After nearly fifteen minutes of no attention or service we got up and left. No one even gave us a look. I've eaten here before so it wasn't any busier than other times I've gone there. Very disappointed to se... View all feedback.
Have been going there for years. Great value for your money. Food is always excellent. Owner and staff very friendly. Best marinated steak around. Love going there due to great owner/staff and food. A on my review.
So far this has been a good experience, we come from Lindenhurst to eat here probably 2 maybe 3 times a month. We've been coming here for about 4 months now . It's nothing fancy , BUT THE SERVICE IS GREAT last nite our waitress was named Michelle and it was amazing. The food is always cooked to order .
I used to love this place because I enjoyed their burgers. However, my husband ordered the hot open turkey plate, and my friend had the hot open roast beef plate. Both dishes had very little meat and were only warm instead of hot. To my surprise, I found out they were using Boar's Head cold cuts, which seemed overpriced for what we received. Unfortunately, I won't be returning.
Great service from the bar tender orded cheese burger fries the best burger I found.
Definitely a locals place... Great value and nothing fancy... The food was good, service was good and prices were very reasonable. Portions are huge and we ended up bringing home half of our orders. It seems like they get a mostly older clientele here. Been coming here for years but not often enough.
Full Menu
Japanese Specialties
Sandwiches
Burger
Alcoholic Drinks
More information
QR-code link to the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.4 / 5 (2072 reviews)#13 Seafood in Brookhaven AmericanVarney's
Montauk Highway 2109, 11719 Brookhaven, US
"The top lobster roll in Long Island."
★ 4.1 / 5 (5320 reviews)#15 Seafood in Brookhaven PizzaPainters' Restaurant
South Country Road 416, 11719-9409 Brookhaven, US
"I booked for my daughter and her friends, they had a great time."
★ 4.3 / 5 (468 reviews)#21 Pizza in Brookhaven BreakfastBrook House Pizza Grill
2478 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven I-11719-9448, United States
"I have to tell you honestly the pizza bread was the only thing I liked about it. Really didn't care for the sause and cheese. Sorry just being honest...."