Painters' Restaurant - Brookhaven

Seafood, Pizza, Continental
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Painters' Restaurant.

Painters' Restaurant

Painters' Restaurant
3.5 / 5 (5496 reviews)

Description

Pampano is a popular choice for those looking for delicious Mexican seafood in midtown Manhattan. The restaurant is known for its great atmosphere, excellent food, and outstanding service. Some highlights include the shrimp quesadilla, the homemade guacamole, and chips, and the option to sit outside on the deck. While the prices may be a bit high for some, the consistency and quality of the food make it worth it for many customers. Overall, Pampano is a must-visit for those seeking a taste of Mexico in the heart of New York City.

Last update: 21.06.2026 from: Richard

Reservation request for Painters' Restaurant

Submit Reservation Request

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 5496 reviews
richard-koch-doctor6
13.06.2026

Our Teddy Bear Run( motorcycle charity ride) after party was here. The food was great.. the staff did a great job considering you had like 100 bikers all come in at the same time. If the ride keeps getting bigger they may have to find a bigger venue

dennis-brunner-2
13.06.2026

Great place to have dinner and they offer live entertainment on the weekends. Food was very good and a good variety of options. Service as always was consistently good.

priscila-grant-churc
13.06.2026

Very nice experience here. The food is delicious, and the atmosphere is very relaxed and comfortable. I was a guest at a private dinner party. Exquisite modern art works by local artists to gaze at after dinner, and the background music is super enjoyable. BTW, i had the fried mozzawith the chopped salad. Definitely recommend.

marlene-is-key-cat18
13.06.2026

I really love the entire concept of Painters but simply cannot do a 5 star and here is why: location is terrible and the parking is always aggravating! It’s literally in the middle of the woods with a hard left turn, unless you’re coming from Bellport. The space inside is awesome, very spacious with clean bathrooms. The service on the day we went was a bit slow even though it was not busy and close to holidays in December. My brother and I ordered mussels to start, the portion was not as large a

william-winter-weed5
13.06.2026

I haven’t been to Painters in a very long time due to moving away from Bellport. I was extremely impressed by the beet salad and sesame tuna dish. The flavor profile was spot on. Wow! Bartender was professional and alert to his surroundings. I highly recommend. Nothing to improve on based on my first visit in over 20 years.

FAQ

The menus that you can eat here, are made with ingredients sourced directly from surrounding farms.

The premises on site are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physical disabilities.

You can also pay for your meals with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.