Corner Pizza - Brookhaven

The male cashier wearing glasses was very unfriendly. He rolled his eyes when I asked for my sliced pizza to go while my friend ordered for dining in. He also d... read more The male cashier wearing glasses was very unfriendly. He rolled his eyes when I asked for my sliced pizza to go while my friend ordered for dining in. He also didn’t explain which toppings would incur an extra charge if I wanted a piece of the deluxe pizza. I ended up paying $9.16 for a small slice, and honestly, the taste doesn’t justify the price for such a tiny portion. It's no surprise there haven’t been any recent reviews.

Great pizza at reasonable prices! I ordered a half salad and two slices of pepperoni pizza for just $11 (including tip). It was pretty quiet at noon, but the pl... read more Great pizza at reasonable prices! I ordered a half salad and two slices of pepperoni pizza for just $11 (including tip). It was pretty quiet at noon, but the place started to get busy as I was leaving. I'll definitely be back. The salad was hearty enough on its own to fill me up!

I have to say, this was one of my least favorite pizza experiences. I really wanted to enjoy it, but I only ended up eating one slice because the smell and tast... read more I have to say, this was one of my least favorite pizza experiences. I really wanted to enjoy it, but I only ended up eating one slice because the smell and taste were off. The garlic bread was just a slice of baguette with a bit of Parmesan on top. It's possible we visited on an off night, but I don't think I'll be going back for their pizza again.

If burnt crust is your taste, then you'll like this pizza. It was meh. It would do in a pinch but not my first choice. The salad wasn't anything impressive but... read more If burnt crust is your taste, then you'll like this pizza. It was meh. It would do in a pinch but not my first choice. The salad wasn't anything impressive but still a salad. Service was fine but not friendly.

First I was born and raised in NYC and Long Island. I called today to try this pizza, pictures looked great so I ordered a large pie with one request, no parmig... read more First I was born and raised in NYC and Long Island. I called today to try this pizza, pictures looked great so I ordered a large pie with one request, no parmigiana cheese, which is not used in Italy. Person answering phone says we don’t put it on. Well as soon as I put pie in car, it’s smells of parmigiana cheese, I’m not happy. So crust is great, sauce is good but they don’t follow instructions. Back to Fellini pizza, they follow instructions.