Rosati's Pizza - Brookfield

I don't want to sound too critical because I really do enjoy Rosati's Pizza when it's made properly. My family and I have ordered from this location many times,... read more I don't want to sound too critical because I really do enjoy Rosati's Pizza when it's made properly. My family and I have ordered from this location many times, and there are plenty of occasions when the pizza is excellent. However, last night marked at least the third or fourth time the crust tasted like cardboard, and there have been instances where the sauce tasted just like plain tomato sauce. I'm hoping this feedback will draw some attention and encourage them to achieve more consistency.

The food is good, but they charge over $4 for delivery. Everyplace else does free pizza delivery, so this was a huge surprise. So all in all, it was $32 for a m... read more The food is good, but they charge over $4 for delivery. Everyplace else does free pizza delivery, so this was a huge surprise. So all in all, it was $32 for a medium 3 topping pizza (including $2 tip) The only reason why I didn?t decide to cancel theorder was because I misheard the person on the other line. I thought she said the total was $21 not $29 I could?ve ordered viaDoor Dash for the same price but wanted to avoid the extra fee, yet they sting you with it anyway. Even though their pizza isgood, I now have to order elsewhere

I've been eating Rosati's pizza for over 40 years and this is the first time I've been disappointed in the quality of the food. This is the first time I've orde... read more I've been eating Rosati's pizza for over 40 years and this is the first time I've been disappointed in the quality of the food. This is the first time I've ordered from this particular location and I've recently ordered from several other locations thatwere excellent, per usual. The ingredients were scarce. I ordered an 18 in with pepperoni and sausage and over half the piecesdid not have even part of the sausage on the slice. I love cheese so I always order extra and with most Rosita's pizzas thismeans I get a lot of cheese. I'm pretty sure this wasn't even as much cheese as a regular order from other locations. Whatreally sent me over the edge and caused me to leave this review was the absurdly small piece of tiramisu. You can see from thephoto I posted that it's maybe four bites and that's with the fork they supplied. Hardly worth $7 even though it's great becausethey can't cheap out on ingredients for this menu item. Thankfully there are enough locations nearby that have always beengreat. I will definitely wait a while to try this location again.

We have been dining at this restaurant for years, and it consistently offers the best pizza we've ever tasted—the sausage has just the right amount of spice! Do... read more We have been dining at this restaurant for years, and it consistently offers the best pizza we've ever tasted—the sausage has just the right amount of spice! Don’t miss out on the Cheef Italian beef sandwich; it’s a hearty meal all on its own!

We were in town for a skate competition with a group of 50 people and decided to order pizza at the last minute for our hotel. We ordered 15 extra-large pizzas... read more We were in town for a skate competition with a group of 50 people and decided to order pizza at the last minute for our hotel. We ordered 15 extra-large pizzas from Rosati's, and it turned out to be a fantastic choice. Both the skaters and their parents loved it! The service at pickup was exceptional—our pizzas were hot, and they even assisted us with loading them into the car. We can't wait to return on our next visit to Wisconsin. Thank you!