Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Andrés Felipe Sierra likes about Tony's Pier:
A staple of City Island, this eatery is located at the shore with a view of the water and nearby bridge (maybe the Whitestone but I'm not sure) Don't expect anything fancy, think of it as the McDonald's of seafood View all feedback.
What Priestly Canty doesn't like about Tony's Pier:
Quiet on a Tuesday afternoon. They have very affordable prices on the menu. The customer service behind the counter could be better. One of staff was kind of rude. As far as the food, they give you 2 big pieces of Whiting. I don't think they fillet it though because it was way to much bones in it for me. The fried Shrimp were crispy, and seasoned well. That was good. The Punch You In The Mouth Drink was nice and stro... View all feedback.
I have never been here and had little to no expectations, but was pleasantly surprised by a line waiting to come in. the line pretty fast and.
My onkel and I visited this restaurant for a late lunch on a Sunday afternoon. the atmosphere, especially outside the seating area, is very scenic and has.
Tonys is similar to the other one who has no ruffles over there, johnny’s reef. they go in, order at the theke and get her eat on a plastic tablet.
I love this place , I hope they keep SECURITY STAFF on point. Very clean for now, Staff is on point and pleasent cordial.
Tony's is similar to the other no frills place across from it, Johnny's Reef. You go inside, order at the counter, and receive your food on a plastic tray with paper plates and plastic cutlery. The menu is mostly fried seafood and they even sell $5 beers and cocktails too. This place is a good option if you want to save some money and do not care to be at a fancier place. Best of all, it is located at the end of island and there is outdoor seating that is right on the water.
Full Menu
Starters & Salads
Entrées
Soups
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
More information
QR-code link to the menu
