Nonna's Pizza Great Kills

We ordered four margaritas, penne Alfredo, salad, and two portions of Tiramisu. Guests of all ages thoroughly enjoyed the pizza and the penne Alfredo. The salad and Tiramisu were particularly favored by the older attendees. Overall, the flavors were outstanding simple yet perfect.

I order take out from here. Not anymore. When you order a pie they don’t give you the size pie they have in the shop. They make their pies smaller than the individual slices they have in the shop. Also they often burn the crust. Nice people inside and good customer service but they make inconsistent pies. I ordered a pie and extra slices. Below is a pic of two extra slices next three slices from the whole pie. Can you pick out which is which?

Very upset. Been coming here because the pizza is life changing but got charged $14 for 6 frozen mozzarella sticks? Violated me

Hands-down, fabulous pizza! Unfortunately, Nonna’s does not have an area for customers to sit down and enjoy the pizza and other menu items. There was only three stools in the front by the window with very little wiggle room. I came all the way from Pennsylvania only to find out that I could not sit down with my daughters and enjoy Nonna’s pizza. It was a big let down for all of us. We couldn’t take it out because there was no place that we could go to eat it except in the car. We had to leave and go elsewhere, but I still ordered four slices to go to take home to Pennsylvania. I found that some of the pizzerias in Staten Island do more delivery than anything else, so it’s not in their best interest to provide sit down service.

The perfect old fashioned pizza place. Staff is always friendly and helpful. Food is top notch. Simple no frills pizza place to grab a slice or a pie to take home.