Hearth, New York - Broad Channel

My wife and myself had dinner Saturday February 23 rd . We arrived early and they were able to seat us immediately. We got the food tasting menu but not the wine tasting menu and it was excellent. I am a big eater and we couldn't finish all the food . Hope to return someday.

The pictures online honestly don't do this place justice. A very cozy and cute spot. Great for a date night or girls night out. Cute bar when you come in but it is tiny so I would come early. The bartender and staff here are so friendly and accommodating. Service is on point here. Our waitress knew the menu very well. Came here with my girlfriends for an easy night out and tried their restaurant week menu. Unlike some places, here they do not skimp just because you are ordering for restaurant week. My girlfriends tried the wine pairing that was offered with the menu and loved it. The choices went perfectly with their meals and we are trying to find the dessert wine they offered! Sweet and refreshing. My only deductions are that I thought some things were just a little under seasoned but it was just me. I had the pear pecorino salad and I felt as if it needed either a little more pear to cut the bitterness of the salad or maybe some gorgonzola. The meatballs were great. The veal to me needed just a little bit more seasoning but aside from that was good. And each and every one of the desserts was delicious!! I would highly recommend coming here.

A perfectly adequate meal was marred by inattentive and sullen staff. We walked into the restaurant shortly before 6 pm, and except for two or three tables the room was empty, and yet we had to wait almost twenty minutes before the waiter came to our table. When they came, their demeanor was suitable for a funeral. We ordered food, which was swiftly delivered to another table that had just arrived. We pointed out the mistake, and then had to wait another twenty minutes before we were served. We then ordered a second round of drinks, and when they arrived the waiter walked away leaving the empty glasses on the table. The service was shockingly, shockingly bad.

Server got appetizer and entree wrong, didn’t even apologize. They’re giving smaller portions at higher prices, hard to justify $24 for 3 meatballs and no sides at this point.

Best wine list, thank you Christine. Everyone is wonderful and a pro.