City Island Lobster House

Met with friends from Long Island and we came from down from Rockland County. Had a three hour lunch. No one rushed us, food was delicious and there were large portions. The owner came by to see how everything was and talked to us for awhile. We will definitely be back. Great day.

You get attention fast the food is delicious, portions are big really worth the trip, the owner goes to your table and have a nice conversation with the costumers

The service at City Island Lobster house is fabulous. The seafood salad is delicious as well as the shrimp Parmesan. The fresh shrimp in the seafood salad are outstanding. After a winter day of road-tripping or just a visit to City Island, put City Island Lobster house on your bucket list and you will always return for the great food and atmosphere! Do not forget the baked red snapper which was also delicious!

Food is delicious. Very nice people working there. Drink specials are yummy. Just Needs better parking situation.

I don’t know how this place has even 4stars… it has changed drastically. There is absolutely no flavor at all in their food. It is so BLAND and extremely expensive for no reason.. you’re better off going to one of those Asian crab places on LI. Idk how they are still open with these prices horrible food