Reviews
What Leanne doesn't like about Carnegie Pizza:
Maybe it was that we didn't get to eat it until we got home, but it wasn't quite as good as we wanted it to be. They also forgot our garlic knots. Just wished it was better. View all feedback. What Joshua C likes about Carnegie Pizza:
I swear the negative reviews must be from other pizza joints or people the owners have wronged. This place has very good pizza. We’ve been eating northeast pizza for over 40 years between Boston NY. This pizza is very good. It’s not the best I’ve had but it’s nowhere close to being the worst. Giving this place a one start review is clearly for spite or some other reason. We tried plain cheese, white pizza, pepperoni/... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Great Pizza, if this was in another city I might give 5 however in NYC the bar is high. Nice and hot, great crust, nice and thin. My quest continues for a 5 in...
read moreAwesome New York pizza, highly recommend. Pictured below is the Buffalo chicken pizza and vodka pizza. The taste was great and the crust was crispy. Seating was...
read moreOf the pizzerias I visited in NYC, this was the best without a doubt, delicious and fast delivery.
Terrible food. Burnt crust. Not NY pizza. This is commercialized for the tourists that frequent these streets. I would never eat here again. The price was crazy...
read moreReally, really good pizza. We ate inside for lunch and went back for dinner. Recommend!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more