Brewster Pastry - BREWSTER
Brewster Pastry
Description
Brewster Pastry is a charming, old-world bakery known for authentic European breads, flaky croissants, standout cakes (Napoleon, tiramisu), cookies, and seasonal fruit cobblers. Fresh daily baking, fair prices, and attentive, generous service—especially for special orders—make it a regional destination for locals and visitors alike. While consistently lauded for quality and variety, reviewers note occasional cleanliness issues with display cases that the shop should address.
Images
Feedback
I absolutely adore this charming little bakery, and I haven’t had a disappointing experience yet. They offer fresh bread, cakes, pastries, and hot soups. There’s always something delightful to sample!
This past weekend, I purchased a Tiramisu cake and a few cupcakes, and they were fantastic. The only reason I'm giving 4 stars instead of 5 is the state of the shop and display cases. They were full of crumbs and debris, and it appeared they hadn't been cleaned in quite some time. To make matters worse, I spotted a dead fly—not in the case where I chose my desserts, but in the one right by the entrance. If this bakery hadn't been recommended to me, I likely wouldn't have gone in, but I felt bad for turning away. The store really needs a thorough cleaning, especially since it serves food!
I ordered a Napoleon cake for my mother-in-law's birthday, and it was absolutely incredible! It was by far the best Napoleon cake I've ever had. The rainbow cookies and Linzer tarts were also fantastic! I absolutely love this place!
Everything I’ve gotten from here is amazing. I especially recommend the almond croissants! Love seeing them at the farmer’s market but their bread and pastries are always worth a trip to Brewster Food: 5
Brewster Pastry is an absolute gem! I always purchase their bread, cookies, and pastries, and they never disappoint. I’ve also used them for special occasions, including our grand opening party and my daughter’s college graduation, and the feedback was unanimous—everyone raved about how fresh and delicious everything was! Even though they aren’t local to me, I gladly make the hour-long drive because their quality is simply unmatched. Every bite is worth it! On top of their incredible baked goods, the staff is absolutely wonderful—always friendly, welcoming, and accommodating. If you’re looking for top-tier pastries and excellent service, Brewster Pastry is 100% worth the trip. Highly recommend! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
