Brewster Pastry

I absolutely adore this charming little bakery, and I haven’t had a disappointing experience yet. They offer fresh bread, cakes, pastries, and hot soups. There’s always something delightful to sample!

I ordered a Napoleon cake for my mother-in-law's birthday, and it was absolutely incredible! It was by far the best Napoleon cake I've ever had. The rainbow cookies and Linzer tarts were also fantastic! I absolutely love this place!

This past weekend, I purchased a Tiramisu cake and a few cupcakes, and they were fantastic. The only reason I'm giving 4 stars instead of 5 is the state of the shop and display cases. They were full of crumbs and debris, and it appeared they hadn't been cleaned in quite some time. To make matters worse, I spotted a dead fly—not in the case where I chose my desserts, but in the one right by the entrance. If this bakery hadn't been recommended to me, I likely wouldn't have gone in, but I felt bad for turning away. The store really needs a thorough cleaning, especially since it serves food!

A chocolate chip cookie. Although they didn't have the kind I wanted, I was NOT disappointed. I have her Italian wedding cookies that are very good. The real star was this Rosin Zimtbunker. It's full of citrus and spices. I can't wait to buy another one. I wish I bought more! So excited to have stumbled over this place.

The owner of this shop saved the day for me quite literally!! I purchased a cake from a friend of mine in Danbury, CT. For a special birthday party all the way in Long Island. Well on my journey to Long Island the cake suddenly started to collapse. I called this bakery and the owner kindly allowed me to come in. He saw the tears in my eyes, and our of kindness of his heart, he fixed the cake. He somehow miraculously made it look as if the cake wasn’t falling apart. I’m so impressed with this bakery and his knowledge in cakes. I should of just bought through him! At the end of it all he didn’t even charge me to help me out and said just pass on the kindness Thankful to of met him and I’m thankful for all his help beyond words!! AMAZING OWNER AND AMAZING BUSINESS!!