Reviews
What Jake Snyder doesn't like about New York City Pizza:
I came in after trying (and failing) to get a sandwich at Which Which (employee would have rather been on their personal cell phone call on speaker). I asked if they did pizza ‘by the slice’ and the employee was very hostile and unfriendly. It was clear they did not want any business to interfere with their slow day. I walked out, as it as clear I wasn’t wanted. Bad vibes! View all feedback. What TygaLily Oldesoul likes about New York City Pizza:
New Yorker here. Transplanted a few years now- tried every joint around nuthin. Most were absolute garbage- don't even know how they stay in business. Til we found this place thanks to some fellow NYers that followed us to the area. Finally something we can actually call pizza?It's on par with alot of places back on LI. We are up in Beaufort but anytime we go down towards Bluffton we grab a pie to go. Like anything e... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
New Yorker here. Transplanted a few years now- tried every joint around nuthin. Most were absolute garbage- don't even know how they stay in business. Til we fo...
read moreAs close as you can get to New York style pizza in the south. Great taste of home when your hundreds of miles away ?
Love this place. Consistently delicious every time. Service is excellent. Definitely a favorite of the whole family
Just had pizza at the Bluffton Buckwalter location. Was this location sold recently and New owners. I ask because the quality, size and toppings are totally dif...
read moreI came in after trying (and failing) to get a sandwich at Which Which (employee would have rather been on their personal cell phone call on speaker). I asked if...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more