The Fish - Bemus Point

Seafood, Fish, French
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

The Fish

The Fish
3.2 / 5 (245 reviews)

Description

The multifaceted experience at this restaurant showcases both charming moments and distressing issues. While the decor is appealing and some dishes, notably crab legs and fish platters, receive high praise, diners frequently report significant service shortcomings. Customers have encountered unkempt conditions, including flies and sticky floors, alongside long waits for food and drinks, often leaving them feeling neglected by staff. Despite these shortcomings, the friendly service from certain staff members and picturesque lakeside views provide a silver lining. Overall, while the potential is evident, improvements in service and cleanliness are crucial for a more consistent dining experience.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: User

Feedback

★ 3.2 / 5 from 245 reviews

We had a big party reservation and ended as the only ones in the restaurant for lunch (after Christmas on the day). our waitress was very friendly and helpful, even helped us make some group photos. everyone enjoyed eating, especially the rust and the fish (sandwiches). the restaurant is very beautiful inside and has a beautiful view of the lake.

I fought last year for birthday. personal and service were good, but the shrimp app I received was not the same as the first one that ordered my group. they served like a popcorn garnel that were not big or as good as the first ones - but they loaded the same so I was not really impressed that but the crab legs were great.

I really enjoyed the soup and salad I had for lunch. The view while eating was lovely. The service was great and the prices were reasonable.

The service at this restaurant is atrocious! During our visit last week, there were only two waiters for the entire place which was completely overwhelmed. Despite their best efforts, it was an impossible task for them to manage. Without a hostess, a line of people waited to be seated. An elderly woman even tried to make a reservation for a large group the following week, only to be told to come back at another time by a waitress. Why are there so few employees working here? Is it due to low wages or poor working conditions? Although the restaurant is lovely with a view of the sea, they will not survive the summer season if they do not hire more help.

Came in for a night cap. Bartender poured us good drinks then shut the place down when the dudes at the bar started getting out of hand. Well done.

Menu

  • Soups

    Creamy Lobster Crab Bisque
    Creamy Lobster Crab Bisque

    Backfin crab; lobster; sherry; cream. Served + oyster crackers

    $9.9
  • Signature Bowls

    Shrimptastic Bowl
    Shrimptastic Bowl

    Breaded shrimp; lettuce; corn; black beans; pico de gallo; jasmine rice + a sweet chili mayo plum sauce. Served + house cooked tortilla chips

    $15.9
  • Bowls

    Grilled Mahi-Mahi Bowl
    Grilled Mahi-Mahi Bowl

    Mahi‐mahi; mango salsa; lettuce; corn; black beans; pico de gallo jasmine rice. Served + house cooked tortilla chips

    $16.9
  • Salads

    Lakeside Salad
    Lakeside Salad

    Spinach; Romaine; Iceberg; cucumber; bell peppers; cherry tomatoes; carrots; red onions; croutons your choice of dressing. Dressing Selection: Ranch; Balsamic; Blue Cheese; Lemon Basil Vinaigrette; Italian

    $12.9
  • Gourmet Burgerz

    Crabby Patty Burger
    Crabby Patty Burger

    Lump crab; Creole remoulade; lettuce; red onion; tomato on brioche. Substitute gluten‐free bun at no charge. All sandwiches served + fries

    $13.9

FAQ

You can use the WLAN of the restaurant free of charge.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.