Papa John's Pizza - Bellbrook

Pizza, International, Fast Food
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +19374348787

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Papa John's Pizza from Bellbrook featuring all 16 dishes and drinks can be found here on the list.

This local pizzeria offers a tantalizing range of pizzas at attractive prices, making it a popular choice for takeout. While some diners rave about the quick online ordering and friendly service—with highlights on affordable deals—it’s clear that experiences can vary significantly. Several customers report issues with order accuracy, long wait times, and indifferent management, leading to frustration. Regular patrons appreciate the gluten-free options and overall taste, but inconsistencies in service suggest a need for managerial improvement. While it has potential, diners may want to weigh their options before making it their go-to spot.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Melissa

Images

Papa John's Pizza Food Papa John's Pizza Inside Papa John's Pizza Food Papa John's Pizza Food Papa John's Pizza Food Papa John's Pizza Food Papa John's Pizza Food Papa John's Pizza Outside

Feedback

★ 2.5 / 5 from 408 reviews

Was Tiffany D at Papa John's Pizza a mag?
I had dinner here and it was great! I ordered online, which was quick and easy. I picked up a large pepperoni pizza for just $9.99, and it was hot and ready when I arrived. The staff member was friendly and handed me my pizza in no time. The atmosphere was lively, with everyone working hard. I highly recommend this place if you're craving a delicious pizza! View all feedback.

What Allen Cox dislikes about Papa John's Pizza:
Had a crew of 7 associates and couldn’t get my order ready took a hour with 2 10 inch pizzas. Staff was rude manager was yelling at staff no wonder can’t get anything right. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 View all feedback.

tiffany-d-church23
Tiffany 25.10.2023 - 01:03

I had dinner here and it was great! I ordered online, which was quick and easy. I picked up a large pepperoni pizza for just $9.99, and it was hot and ready when I arrived. The staff member was friendly and handed me my pizza in no time. The atmosphere was lively, with everyone working hard. I highly recommend this place if you're craving a delicious pizza!

terrill-wilson
Terrill 25.10.2023 - 01:03

Service: Takeout Food: 4/5 Service: 5/5 Atmosphere: 4/5

amy-voshall
amy 25.10.2023 - 01:03

**Delivery Meal Type:** Dinner **Price per Person:** $1–10 **Food Rating:** 5/5 **Service Rating:** 5/5 **Atmosphere Rating:** 5/5 **Recommended Dishes:** Chocolate Brownie, Stuffed Crust Pizza Absolutely fantastic experience! I ordered dinner for delivery, and it completely exceeded my expectations. At just $1–10 per person, the value is incredible. The food was top-notch, especially the chocolate brownie and stuffed crust pizza, both of which earned a perfect score. The service was outstanding, with prompt delivery and friendly communication. As for the atmosphere, even though I enjoyed my meal at home, I could tell that the restaurant itself would have a great vibe. Highly recommend giving this place a try!

melissa-conley
Melissa 22.02.2025 - 01:16

I ordered 3 pizza’s and bread sticks. My total including tip was $72 through the call center. I paid via credit card which was approved and deducted from my account. There was however a glitch at Papa Johns that didn’t show the payment attached to my order. My only option according to the call center was to pay for my order again and to wait 3-5 days to get reimbursed for their mistake. I called the actual store hoping a manager could help straighten out the order. I was screamed at by the employee who answered and told that was my only option. I asked to speak to a manger again and she screamed again that she was hanging up on me. Top notch! I guess in 3 to 5 days I’ll be able to afford dinner.

jack-newell
Jack 22.02.2025 - 01:16

Great crust and pizza.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.