The Penny Pub - Bay Shore

We ordered fish and chips with excitement as the pub is located in a beautiful coastal area. The menu said beer battery. What came out was frozen fish fried. The flat rectangular frozen fish fried. Absolutely disgusting for $16 worth of food. Do not recommend this place at all. I tried to call the manager because I don't want to leave any bad reviews. Never again from the manager. I totally ignored my complaint.

Nice place of Rum Punsch was delicious. But the pièce de résistance last night for me was the karaoke with Alex who happens every Wednesday night. We're making fun of what could happen on a random Wednesday night. Alex his team was cool hip friendly and welcoming. The karaoke is free, why not take Do you buy a friend head in the penny pub a drink or two a few hours pure unfiltered fun? Are you back next Wednesday?????

Definitely recommend when Ashley works. She's such a sweet heart and cares for everyone. One of the most beautiful bartenders I've ever met. She brilliant!!!

I walked in and approached the bar to order a beer and a guy with an Icelander hat with a sweater, who said “pear” said “Can I help you?” In a disgusting way for me. I said, “I just order a beer, is that okay?” Other guests who went to the bar he went another answer like “Hello welcome you guys here for the Fundraiser”. In a calming voice. Obviously some racist employees. Great service at the bar otherwise. But the guy with the island hat tonight obviously has no hospitality or service experience. He could have met me differently

I was just visting NY and it was my first time at this place. I LOVED it! The pumpkin pie martini was amazing as was the food. Seems like anything on the menu is excellent. Bartender was all smiles and great service!Food: 5/5