Slice Of Bay Shore

Absolutely delicious! I was genuinely impressed by everything on the chef's menu—just wow! My favorite dish was the bacon-wrapped scallops, but the steak with latkes was a very close second. I couldn't stop talking about the pumpkin pie cheesecake; it was simply amazing! I'm already looking forward to returning to try some of their fantastic pizzas and the new items on the rotating chef's menu.

I was in search of a unique and budget-friendly option for Valentine's Day when I discovered this restaurant on Facebook. The pizza was absolutely amazing! It was cooked perfectly, topped generously with pepperoni, and featured a lovely heart shape. I was pleasantly surprised to see that it had eight slices! The best part is that they offer this heart-shaped pizza all year long! So delicious!

The atmosphere of the restaurant creates a genuinely enjoyable dining experience. It's spotless, and even the restroom is impeccably clean! I could rave about this place for hours, but as Doug wisely noted, you should absolutely make a trip to Slice of Bay Shore without hesitation! I drove 41 miles from Lower Manhattan to 298 W Main St in Bay Shore, and I would happily make that drive again week after week!

WOW!!!!! Unfortunately, poor management and inexperienced ownership have caused Slice of Bayshore to decline more quickly than I anticipated. The Bayshore community has lost a wonderful restaurant. I wish Mike all the best!!!! Terry Rally

I've ordered pizza from this place multiple times, and I have to say, it never gets better. The crust is too doughy and falls apart too easily. Plus, the sauce tastes quite sour. What kind of pizza is this? I live in New York!