White Buffalo Trading Post - Barnstead

Pizza, Burgers, Ice Cream
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

White Buffalo Trading Post

White Buffalo Trading Post
3.6 / 5 (26 reviews)

Description

White Buffalo Trading Post has quickly become a local favorite, especially among newcomers, thanks to its generously portioned, flavorful subs, calzones, and pizzas. Many praise the friendly, family-run atmosphere and consistently enjoy every bite. However, some longtime patrons have expressed disappointment with recent changes, citing cold, hard rolls and inconsistencies like small onion ring servings and order errors. While prices are perceived as high by some, the overall consensus leans toward White Buffalo offering some of the best subs in the area, making it a must-try for those seeking hearty, satisfying meals in a welcoming setting.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: User

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 26 reviews
barbara-c-bank897
30.09.2024

Just moved to the area from the city where we had lots of choices for take out and i must say i am elated to have found white buffalo trading post in my new neighborhood! By far the BEST subs, calzone pizza that we have ever gotten in the city!! Friendly staff and lovely family owned business. I would pay DOUBLE for the food they serve because the portions are great but more importantly you ENJOY every bite!

barb-g-bird382
30.09.2024

Recently moved to this lovely town and have tried subs at all the local establishments and I can say that White Buffalo has the BEST subs , hands down! Not only local but I moved here from Arlington Ma and they are better than I could find even there. Can 't wait to try the calzone and pizza!

dee-moran-1
30.09.2024

This used to be our favorite place for subs, but no longer. It seems they keep their rolls refrigerated now, so even when you get them home they are still hard and cold, and need to be microwaved to soften the up. The prices are high, we had two cold subs and some onion rings and the bill was $22.00! And the large order of onion rings turned out to be literally 8 rings...which we discovered when we opened the bag at home!! would hardly be considered a SMALL ! Totally got cheated there! AND they didn 't get the order right, had no hots on them which I asked for. From now on it 's Alton House of Pizza...always! You lost us on this one.

Recently moved to this beautiful city and tried underwater in all local facilities and I can say that White Buffalo has the BEST substrates, hands down! Not only locally, but I moved here from Arlington Ma and they are better than I could even find there. Can't wait to try the calzone and pizza!

Moving to the area of the city where we had many choices to take out and I must say I'm elated to have found white buffalo trading mail in my new neighborhood! By far the BEST Subs, Calzone Pizza we'll ever get in town!! Friendly staff and beautiful family businesses. I would pay DOUBLE for the food they serve because the portions are big, but importantly you ENJOY every bite!

FAQ

The restaurant offers complimentary WLAN for its visitors.

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR-Code zur Speisekarte von White Buffalo Trading Post

Suggested nearby restaurants.