American Pie - Barnesville

The pizza, buffalo balls, and cheesebread were all delicious. The staff was friendly and the restaurant was always clean. However, I had to deduct three stars b... read more The pizza, buffalo balls, and cheesebread were all delicious. The staff was friendly and the restaurant was always clean. However, I had to deduct three stars because none of the employees were wearing masks. One coworker briefly put on a mask to serve a customer, but that was the extent of it. Disappointing.

The restaurant offers large pizzas, but the service is lacking. Despite multiple attempts to call and place an order, there was no answer. Despite seeing staff... read more The restaurant offers large pizzas, but the service is lacking. Despite multiple attempts to call and place an order, there was no answer. Despite seeing staff inside and open for business, no one answered the phone.

Forest provided exceptional customer service when there was an accident with our pizza coming out of the kitchen. He not only came over to our table to sincerel... read more Forest provided exceptional customer service when there was an accident with our pizza coming out of the kitchen. He not only came over to our table to sincerely apologize, but also refunded our order and brought us dessert! The Aloha Pizza, BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza, Cinnamon Balls, and Butter Balls were all delicious. Forest's handling of our issue, along with the rest of the staff, exemplified excellent customer service. Thanks again to all of you!

I absolutely adored the vegetarian pizza! It was delicious and a perfect size. This restaurant offers some of the top pizza in Barnesville. read more I absolutely adored the vegetarian pizza! It was delicious and a perfect size. This restaurant offers some of the top pizza in Barnesville.

That's really not a bad pizza thing. it is always busy and they make a pizza buffet bar most days (not my thing, but for some it could be). her pizza is not. read more That's really not a bad pizza thing. it is always busy and they make a pizza buffet bar most days (not my thing, but for some it could be). her pizza is not.