Five Guys - Baraboo

Fries were soggy and greasy. Bag was so greasy. Cook was very dirty looking. Have always gotten fresh mushrooms on burgers, supervisor told me the only had grilled mushrooms and it was against store policy to give fresh ones.

I visited for the first time and absolutely loved it. I only wish there was a location closer to where I live. Everything was incredibly fresh and delicious. I appreciated that they shared the origin of the potatoes, and the peanuts they served while we waited for our meal were a delightful surprise. Despite being quite busy for a Tuesday afternoon in October, they managed to prepare our food promptly without sacrificing quality. I'm really impressed and hope to return soon!

The restaurant is definitely overpriced. For a meal for six of us (including four children), we ended up spending $85 for burgers and hot dogs. While the burgers were decent, the fries were undercooked, the grilled cheese was quite small, and the hot dogs were just okay. Unfortunately, the quality of the food didn't warrant the high price, and we likely won’t be returning.

The burgers were incredible! The staff was also very friendly; they gave my kids shakes for their birthdays, which was really thoughtful. The shakes were delicious, and my kids loved them. We will definitely be coming back!

The food is delicious, but the price is a bit steep—over $50 for two orders of fries, burgers, and a shake. I would rate the food 4 out of 5, but I don’t think it’s worth that price.