Toole's Cakes - Bainbridge

Delis, Lunch, Cakes
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Toole's Cakes

Toole's Cakes
4.6 / 5 (173 reviews)

Description

Nestled in Five Points, Bainbridge, Toole's Cakes & Deli is a quaint neighborhood bakery and lunch spot known for creative cake decorating, standout cream horns, tasty sandwiches, and an impressive vegan cake that wins over omnivores. A friendly, efficient staff and a tempting display case make it a go-to for casual lunches and celebrations. However, customers report inconsistent cake quality—dry layers and uneven frosting—and occasional lapses in customer service, so order with caution for special occasions.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: angie

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 173 reviews
angie-341
26.07.2023

I was disappointed with the cakes I received. The icing was uneven on both sides, and when I sent a picture to the restaurant, their response was quite unpleasant. It seemed like they frosted the cakes while they were still frozen. I definitely won’t be ordering from them again.

charla-7
26.07.2023

Look at this picture perfect cake Toole’s made for me. Get butter pecan layers it’s so yummy

amanda-46
26.07.2023

I had the best cream horns I've ever tasted at this bakery! The owners are incredibly friendly, and their cake decorating skills are truly impressive. I believe their creativity really distinguishes them from other bakeries in the area. The display case is filled with delightful cupcakes and cookies, which my daughter absolutely loves. The location is also very convenient, right across from Elianos Coffee. This is a fantastic bakery to visit in Bainbridge, GA!

nikki-213
26.07.2023

I'm disappointed to say that some people believe this place is a real bakery with good customer service. My sister ordered a birthday cake for her son about three months ago, and I picked it up for her. Unfortunately, the cake was extremely dry, making everyone need to drink twice as much to wash it down. While it looked decent, it tasted awful—definitely the worst cake I've ever had. My aunt ordered a cake during the holidays, and once again, it was the worst. It was just as dry.

sebastian-320
26.07.2023

Do not recommend As they simply do not any customer service skills. They are happy to charge you for a cake but don’t take their time to try to help you if an incident occurs. My cake fumbled and never once did he ask how to help Mexico. His main concern was “that he didn’t understand how this could happen.

FAQ

The restaurant also takes various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.