Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Jack Dubay likes about Islamorada Fish Company:
Neat place. Came here for Dinner on July 7th. In Asland for training all week for a new job. Came here and had fish Tacos and a couple of IPA's. The bartender was great and the food was delicious. Great place to come to let alone the HUGE fish aquarium. View all feedback.
What Jeannine Ruggieri doesn't like about Islamorada Fish Company:
Spicolli was our waiter and he was amazing! He was handling a lot of tables and did a great job! Super polite!! But…. The food wasn’t great to say the least. My mahi was super dry and tasteless. My husband said his fish and chips were the worst he ever had. The fries were ice cold when they got to us. This was NOT our server’s fault and I hope he gets a raise or a better job! View all feedback.
The managers have to work tables sometimes because of the new normal staff shortages, but they are nice and the food is surprisingly good for a chain restaurant. Not fancy, but a convenient and restful break from shopping in the store.
Service could have been better for the price, but food was awesome
We visited for Fathers Day. Food and service were excellent. Highly recommend the Portofino Mahi and the Fish Tacos! Calamari app was also delicious. Parker, our server, was very helpful with recommendations. We will definitely be back.
Loved every moment.. coming back from a vacation I hoped that this on the way restaurant would pair with the store that is so great. It didn't disappoint. The food was great and our server Elizabeth was awesome.
Server : Stephen visit date :06/10/2024 4:35 PM I recently visited Islamorada fish company and unfortunately had a very disappointing experience. From the outset, the service was disorganized and inattentive. when the chips were served, they not only tasted bad but also had an unpleasant odor. The most concerning issue was discovering a Bug inside one of our tacos. When we reported this to the waiter, he took the plate without an apology or any attempt to rectify the situation He was quite rude and dismissive, simply asking what do u want ? instead of addressing our concerns properly. Despite our requests, no manager was made available to speak with us. Given the combination of poor service, substandard food quality, and lack of proper customer care i cannot recommend Islamorada Fish company, I hope the management takes these issues seriously and makes the necessary improvements.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
