Anthony's - Arbor Avitae

Great food but a bit pricey read more Great food but a bit pricey

We had reservations, they seated people who did not have reservations before us. They also served them before us too.The bar did not have a bartender, dirty gla... read more We had reservations, they seated people who did not have reservations before us. They also served them before us too.The bar did not have a bartender, dirty glasses were all over the bar. We waited 45 minutes and decided to leave.The owner followed us to our car, I thought to apologize, but instead gripped us out and called the police.He lied to the police, saying we had salads, untrue. Everyone in our dining space was waiting for service and food.I told the owner to get some more help.My wife is in the Women's Club, and will be letting friends know.

I don't want anyone else to know about this hidden gem. We found it after several of the areas famous supper clubs were booked over a week out. And boy, were we... read more I don't want anyone else to know about this hidden gem. We found it after several of the areas famous supper clubs were booked over a week out. And boy, were we glad they were. This wasn't just the best meal I've had in the 20+ years of coming to the area. This was one of the best meals I've ever had. Beating out even some restaurants in Italy.The atmosphere feels warm and inviting with a pretty limited amount of tables. But this just added to the feeling that you stepped inside a portal to a mountain town in Italy. The decor is beautiful and perfectly curated.The service was so great. We happened to get sat after two LARGE parties, so understandably, we had to wait perhaps a bit longer than normal. However, again, this just made it feel like a restaurant in Europe that doesn't take away your plate and bring you your check before you're finished chewing. And once the food came... none of the wait mattered. I honestly, would have waited as long as they needed for how good the food was!We ordered the strawberry champagne soup, which was fresh and refreshing. And then we ordered steak and the chicken milanase. Everything was thoughtfully prepared and intentionally put on the plate. We've already been back, and it lived up to the hype again. Leave a message and they will call you back for a reservation. Or don't.. that way it won't stay as busy and we can visit again as soon as we're in town. : Dietary restrictions: Severe dairy allergy that they were more than generous in making accommodations. Kid-friendliness: This is more a date night spot, but they were incredible with our 5 yr old and made her feel like the VIP table.

Our dinner was phenomenal! Potato chip walleye was cooked to perfection. Also great old fashioned. Highly recommend Anthony’s! read more Our dinner was phenomenal! Potato chip walleye was cooked to perfection. Also great old fashioned. Highly recommend Anthony’s!

Reservation was for 7:30. Seated at 8:45. Bartender Tom was great. Server was the worst we’ve EVER had. Shrimp bruschetta was terrible, 4 shrimp, large pieces o... read more Reservation was for 7:30. Seated at 8:45. Bartender Tom was great. Server was the worst we’ve EVER had. Shrimp bruschetta was terrible, 4 shrimp, large pieces of bread, tomatoes galore. Couldn’t find the cheese. Salad, half carrot, uncut, end was black. Topped off with a thick slice of a beet. We didn’t even wait for our entree. Please DO NOT DINE THERE. BRAD DENISE (Indianapolis).