Bortell's - Anna Maria

#23 - Seafood - Anna Maria, Bars, Pizza

Bortell's

Bortell's
3.6 / 5 (530 reviews)

Description

**A Mixed Bag at Bortell's: A Dive into Anna Maria Island's Pub Scene**

Bortell's offers a mixed experience for patrons on Anna Maria Island, with a limited menu and inconsistent service noted by many. While a few appreciate the friendly bartenders and the atmosphere, others lament the absence of beloved pizza and food options. However, the bar shines with its clean environment, an excellent selection of drinks, and great space for catching sports. Overall, it’s a place where visitors can enjoy a cold beer and socialize, but diners may leave disappointed if they expect a robust food menu. A stop for drinks, perhaps, but not a culinary destination.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Sinead

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 530 reviews
brian-opp
23.10.2023

Be sure to try the chicken thumbs—they're gigantic!

brad-r-office6-schoo
23.10.2023

I was lucky enough to be a local on the Island for a few years. Bortells had a full liquor license on the north end of the Island. Enough said :P

james-d-tree26
23.10.2023

Decent food long wait understaffed decent. It pains me to write this. it could be so much better. Im hopeful maybe you will have z as better experience

sinead-amerlynck
21.02.2025

Lovely spot, Kalea Ari are the best. Pizza is easily best on the island easily, full of cool locals. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

k-seidl-2
21.02.2025

The Long Island was a little pricey. I do like the addition of the garage door opening up the place.

FAQ

As a customer, you can use the WLAN of the restaurant free of charge.

There is a TV / screen on-site where sporting events are broadcast.

The diner is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physical disabilities.

You can also pay for your meals with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.