Morty's Oyster Stand - Feedback

We were unsure of what to expect twice, as the restaurant was located where the legendary Cyril's used to be, so it had big shoes to fill.

This restaurant is fantastic in every way. The staff is friendly and welcoming with big smiles, making you never want to leave.

I enjoyed some of the best fried Ipswich clams at this restaurant. They also offer local oysters for $1.50 each during Oyster Happy Hour. The service was good,...

Absolutely epic new roadside restaurant on Montauk Highway, everyone has been freaking out about how good the food is and now I know why. It's unreal, and the s...

Great spot on the stretch! Fresh oysters delivered every day.

The oysters were fresh and delicious but the lobster roll was extremely skimpy and just ok. My friend loved his crab cake. Dessert was disappointing. In general...

So glad we made the choice to pull in here for a lovely, relaxed, oystery and boozy lunch. It?s got the perfect Montauk beach vibe and generous and delicious fr...

This place was such an amazing find. We were visiting for a wedding and had a free day to find some lunch and came here. We had the oysters, fish tacos and trie...

Wonderful setting, very good food, although a bit on the pricy side. The oysters were the best I?ve had anywhere. Lobster roll was good not mind blowing, but eh...

I had an amazing experience at this restaurant. From the ambiance to the food to the service, everything was top-notch. I highly recommend trying the oysters, f...

Morty's is currently closed for the season. We made a reservation but when we arrived, the restaurant was closed for the winter. Disappointing.

We had made a reservation at this restaurant through Open Table, and it was confirmed. However, when we arrived, we found that the restaurant was closed. It wou...

The menu is very restricted with small portion sizes. It is possible that this is due to Covid restrictions. I do not recommend this restaurant and I do not pla...

Lobster rolls were not that good