Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Old Mill Inn:
While it may be a bit off the beaten path, this fantastic local spot in Western New York serves up some of the best burgers, steaks, and wings you'll find anywhere. The rustic atmosphere complements the great selection of food and the long bar, making it an ideal place to enjoy a meal or a drink. If you live in the area, you'll definitely want to visit regularly! View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Old Mill Inn:
Off street parking. Building has been there many years and is kept up in rustic style. Bar and bench seating booths add to charm of the place. Good weeknight specials. Tues is wings deal and they were good with many different sauces to go with them. Good selection of bottled beer. Reasonable prices. Food came quickly and service was good. View all feedback.
Here on the way to cooperstown. other reviews were before place. had lunch fantastic portions and delicious!
Best burger I've had in 30 years, inexpensive and heavy pours at the bar and friendly staff and servers.
Noah, The owner of the Old Mill is great. He's got a great attitude and very knowledgeable and friendly. The Ol Mill has a very good atmosphere and the decor is perfect. The beer selection was great and the bar can make every mix drink possible. I am recommending you stop by grab a beer and a pie. This place is very clean and my food was perfectly cooked, very tasty and served hot. I will be returning very soon!
Off street parking. Building has been there many years and is kept up in rustic style. Bar and bench seating booths add to charm of the place. Good weeknight specials. Tues is wings deal and they were good with many different sauces to go with them. Good selection of bottled beer. Reasonable prices. Food came quickly and service was good.
Nice country tavern, our food was excellent , Philly cheese and 1/2 pound cheese burgers, perfect. Beer and wine at reasonable prices and our waitress Brittany did a excellent job. Can't wait to go back!